undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdartos1y ago0 comments

> what I see on some fiction writing subreddits… the AI is often a genuine improvement over amateur writers

What point are you trying to make here? That amateur writers are amateurs? That AI is only "often" an improvement over an amateur?

> Which is frustrating, because I have the feeling the novel I've been trying to finish writing for the last decade may be usurped by AI before I get my final draft.

This statement shows such a warped attitude towards art and the creative process. What do you mean "usurped?" Do you actually believe that LLMs will overtake humans when it comes to creative works?

If so, you don't really understand what is compelling about the written word or what makes for good writing and reading and it's no wonder you feel as though your own writing is so substandard.

I highly doubt your writing is that bad. Especially if you've been working on it for a decade.

0 comments

ben_w1y ago

Just so we're clear, you're not sure what I'm saying and nevertheless think that I'm a better writer than you believe that I believe myself to be and you are confused by an imaginary "only" that wasn't in what I wrote and that you are skeptical of the idea that an LLM might overtake humans in creative works generally and writing in particular?

I'm not sure if the following statement will help your confusion, but most who judge the quality of a story do so without being able to write that story. Critiquing and writing are different skills.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

ben_w1y ago

I'm not sure if the following statement will help your confusion, but most who judge the quality of a story do so without being able to write that story. Critiquing and writing are different skills.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse