undefined | Better HN

0 pointstheodric1y ago0 comments

I strongly disagree that this is in any way defensible, despite that both Google and AWS do it. You should be able to set a limit, and even if they can't cut off exactly at the limit, they should be able to cut off when you hit (say) 2* your limit, or in the absence of a limit, perhaps issue progressively louder warnings until you hit 10* your usual spend, with the ability for you to give affirmative consent to uncap if you're hoping your app will suddenly take off. Nobody needs to lose their house or their life savings to some teracorp just because "it's hard."

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

adriand1y ago· 2 in thread

I totally agree. You should be able to choose to have things shut down rather go past a limit. I don’t have a single client that would choose $70k versus, say, a couple hours downtime while we figure out what is happening with a resource that is going crazy.

This is where I question the risk of serverless. Although, now that I think about it, while my one client’s EC2 instances are essentially capped in terms of capacity and spend, we also use S3 etc. I suppose it would be entirely possible to accidentally write a huge amount of data to S3. But again I would rather get warnings from the app that writing to S3 has failed due to limits than get a huge bill!

danpalmer1y ago

But you also pay for data at rest in S3. Should S3 stop storing that data while you figure things out? Should they bill the customer for the deletion of that data as they normally would?

I don't disagree on wanting this feature, but it's just not something that's possible to implement in totality when you dig into the details.

adriand1y ago

Could it work based on deviance from norms? Like a setting where you say, I’m okay with up to two standard deviations from our typical write volume but that’s it?

Or, alternatively, just let me set the size of the volume. Treat it like a hard drive?

In terms of your point about the data at rest, part of the issue is that we get a bill once per month, and that’s probably when we would notice it. Of course there is probably a Cloudwatch alarm or something we could set (I assume) but there’s so many damn services…

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse