undefined | Better HN

0 pointsreadthenotes11y ago0 comments

I'm not a libertarian by any means, nor do I think of tax as theft.

But if someone can legitimately take away property because you don't pay them, I don't think it's yours.

0 comments

baseballdork1y ago

Which is why that’s an extremely simplistic view. It’s literally the simplest possible idea of ownership.

readthenotes1OP1y ago

Well, it's certainly less simplistic than "I claim I own it therefore I do"

baseballdork1y ago

And if that was an actual statement people made, then you'd be right to say that. However, I think we can dispense with the strawman. Ownership exists in the real world, which means it necessarily conforms to the laws of the society in which it resides. Your view is a child's perspective on ownership.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsreadthenotes11y ago0 comments

I'm not a libertarian by any means, nor do I think of tax as theft.

But if someone can legitimately take away property because you don't pay them, I don't think it's yours.

0 comments

baseballdork1y ago

Which is why that’s an extremely simplistic view. It’s literally the simplest possible idea of ownership.

readthenotes1OP1y ago

Well, it's certainly less simplistic than "I claim I own it therefore I do"

baseballdork1y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse