undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmjw_byrne1y ago0 comments

"No one wants a preboot password though" - really? Doesn't strike me as particularly inconvenient, especially given the relative rarity of actual bootups these days.

I've been using bog-standard FDE for as long as I can remember. One extra password entry per bootup for almost-perfect security seems like great value to me.

0 comments

zinekeller1y ago

It seems that you're looking at the wrong bubble here. Most people actually detests passwords and would rather use a different method if possible (this is why ordinary users turn on biometric authentication despite some here questioning its security). Adding another password will certainly make users - especially enterprises - complain.

Also for technical reasons, Windows can't do the fancy one login/password screen (which assumes a file-level encryption, which is how it is implemented nowadays to support multiple users [1] [2]). This is due to Windows software that are expecting that everything is an ordinary file (unlike Apple which don't care on that aspect and Android which has compartmentalized storage). Even if we have an EFS-style encryption here, it will be incompatible with enterprise authentication solutions.

1: https://support.apple.com/guide/security/encryption-and-data...

2: https://source.android.com/docs/security/features/encryption

hansvm1y ago

> this is why ordinary users turn on biometric authentication despite some here questioning its security

That's part of the reason. Another part is BigCo spamming the users asking for biometrics or whatever the current promotion-driver is, making opting out hard to find, and using their position of authority to assert that it's "more secure" (for your personal threat model no less, nice to be able to offload thought to a corporation).

devops991y ago

The more inexpensive option of the newer Trezor wallets and "login PIN" as an optional alternative to a password that also works, seems to be the best option (that I have seen so far).

The more recently released Trezor wallets are still new, and Yubikey 5C will probably be used in many places anyway just because of the keyring and no need for the usb-c cable.

whatevaa1y ago

Absolutely. You are an exception. Get your head outside and look around you instead of assuming.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse