undefined | Better HN

0 pointsparanoidrobot1y ago0 comments

Unfortunately, WhatsApp will not let you use it without handing them all of your contacts.

I wanted to remain in contact with a friend that had moved overseas, so local texting/calling was no longer an option. They use iMessage and WhatsApp, and I don't have an iPhone.

I can't add them as a contact, I can't get messages from them, I can't send messages to them - nothing, unless I hand over all of my contacts.

0 comments

frizlab1y ago

That is not actually true, on iOS at least. They will bug you to do it, but you can use whatsapp w/o giving access to your contacts.

paranoidrobotOP1y ago

Unfortunately not on Android.

frizlab1y ago

One of the perks of the AppStore review I guess: it is not allowed to have the app not work if the contacts permission is not granted IIRC :)

switch0071y ago

Grapheneos let's you trick apps into thinking they have all your contacts but you actually give them a sub list ("contact scopes")

na4ma41y ago

On Android I just rejected access to contacts.

Then to add a contact enter their phone number specifically and it works for me.

paranoidrobotOP1y ago

I reinstalled the app just now to re-check.

Click the green 'Add chat' icon.

It prompts: "To help you connect with friends and family, allow WhatsApp access to your contacts" with options for Not now, and Continue.

Not Now closes the dialogue, and returns you to the main chat list.

Continue launches the Android prompt for "Allow WhatsApp to your contacts", clicking Don't Allow returns you to the main chat list.

So, unless there's something else you need to do...

Make a Call works the same way.

I can create a community and a group chat in that, and even send messages to the group.

I can't add anyone to the group though, same "Give us your contacts" thing.

na4ma41y ago

I blocked whatsapp from contacts, so it doesn't popup the prompt anymore, but I don't even get the "to help you connect ..." prompt either.

when I go to the green "add chat" icon, I just get a list with my whatsapp contacts (not system contacts) and if I add a phone number I can talk to them directly (and/or add them to the whatsapp contacts instead of system contacts).

  WhatsApp Messenger
  Version 2.24.24.77

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

frizlab1y ago

That is not actually true, on iOS at least. They will bug you to do it, but you can use whatsapp w/o giving access to your contacts.

paranoidrobotOP1y ago

Unfortunately not on Android.

frizlab1y ago

One of the perks of the AppStore review I guess: it is not allowed to have the app not work if the contacts permission is not granted IIRC :)

switch0071y ago

Grapheneos let's you trick apps into thinking they have all your contacts but you actually give them a sub list ("contact scopes")

na4ma41y ago

On Android I just rejected access to contacts.

Then to add a contact enter their phone number specifically and it works for me.

paranoidrobotOP1y ago

I reinstalled the app just now to re-check.

Click the green 'Add chat' icon.

It prompts: "To help you connect with friends and family, allow WhatsApp access to your contacts" with options for Not now, and Continue.

Not Now closes the dialogue, and returns you to the main chat list.

Continue launches the Android prompt for "Allow WhatsApp to your contacts", clicking Don't Allow returns you to the main chat list.

So, unless there's something else you need to do...

Make a Call works the same way.

I can create a community and a group chat in that, and even send messages to the group.

I can't add anyone to the group though, same "Give us your contacts" thing.

na4ma41y ago

I blocked whatsapp from contacts, so it doesn't popup the prompt anymore, but I don't even get the "to help you connect ..." prompt either.

  WhatsApp Messenger
  Version 2.24.24.77

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse