undefined | Better HN

0 pointsToucanLoucan1y ago0 comments

> It's against the rules to call out hiring companies in the thread, primarily because we don't want off-topic arguments

All due respect: if an employer posts here offering for people to apply, that the employer in question is bad in some way, I don't see why that's considered "off topic." If a company sucks, we owe it to our fellow engineers to get the word out until they improve. A perfect example being the sorts that don't have any intention of filling the jobs they post.

In my mind the only sort of company that would avoid posting here due to the potential of being criticized by the HN userbase are exactly the sorts you don't want posting, so that seems like a win/win.

Just my 0.02.

0 comments

dang1y ago

It's because of the reasons I already mentioned, which are considerable.

emmanueloga_1y ago

> we don't want off-topic arguments and because it would be too easy to exploit it for shenanigans.

Are there any other reasons you mentioned? I only found this one.

Thinking about it, people replying to the post stake their reputation too in whatever they post. If we see a throwaway or newish account causing shenanigans, people interested in the job post can form their own opinion of the nature of the comment? (isn't that what downvoting is for too?).

Since threads have this nice toggle feature you can always click [-] to ignore whatever people is saying about a job posting.

dang1y ago

That's two reasons! (1) It's offtopic, which is especially bad given that the threads are so comment-heavy; and (2) it's too easy to exploit.

I suppose exploit is not the right word, because a lot of it is people posting their grudges or bad feelings that they probably have perfectly legit reasons for, and yet are not the full story. We're not going to get the full story, or even a fair assessment, from a distracting back-and-forth in the middle of a job ads thread; and that's ignoring the point that most people posting to Who Is Hiring aren't in a position to respond to such complaints in the first place.

It seems to me easy to see that if we allowed it, there would be no limit to it, and the end result would be a bad scene indeed.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

dang1y ago

It's because of the reasons I already mentioned, which are considerable.

emmanueloga_1y ago

> we don't want off-topic arguments and because it would be too easy to exploit it for shenanigans.

Are there any other reasons you mentioned? I only found this one.

Since threads have this nice toggle feature you can always click [-] to ignore whatever people is saying about a job posting.

dang1y ago

That's two reasons! (1) It's offtopic, which is especially bad given that the threads are so comment-heavy; and (2) it's too easy to exploit.

It seems to me easy to see that if we allowed it, there would be no limit to it, and the end result would be a bad scene indeed.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse