undefined | Better HN

0 pointsekianjo13y ago0 comments

> I do see people working with iPads quite often.

Maybe I should clarify what I mean by "working". For me, reading information on a screen is not working. Work is when you add value, so when you actually produce something with the information you have. An iPad may be a great tool to READ informatio, at the most take notes, but to produce something it is pretty poor and limited in many aspects. Yes, you can always manage to do something with it, but it's just a big compromise versus using the right device for the right job.

> I suspect desktops will morph into workstations with huge monitors and highish prices, and that laptops will become a high end option for those of us who prefer a keyboard/screen combo.

There is no reason for desktops to become more expensive, though. As long as they are built with mass-market technology, of course.

0 comments

keithpeter13y ago

"For me, reading information on a screen is not working. Work is when you add value, so when you actually produce something with the information you have."

The total market for portable computing devices is growing, and the replacement of e.g. paper manuals by tablets might be one of the reasons. This is work by my definition.

"There is no reason for desktops to become more expensive, though. As long as they are built with mass-market technology, of course."

Many desktops in companies can probably be replaced by tablets/mobile devices. I'm in an open plan staffroom with 60 desks and 60 PCs. Many of my fellow teachers would be very comfortable with a tablet that could talk to a projector somehow and some good writing sketching software. We could halve the number of desktops easily, perhaps just have 10 on desks in the side of the room.

Multiply that all over and you have a reduced market in numbers for desktops.

PS: not sure why your comment is being downvoted, just depends on definition of 'work'. Mine is different.

antidoh13y ago

"Many of my fellow teachers would be very comfortable with a tablet that could talk to a projector somehow and some good writing sketching software."

That's probably good for short and "casual" writing. But for long distance writing, most people can type much faster than they can write, and most people can type much more legibly than they can write.

Which is hugely ironic, given the bandwagon of reducing emphasis on handwriting skills in favor of keyboarding skills in schools. For devices without keyboards, we'll either be using glass keyboards with their tactile inaccuracy, or styluses with OCR software behind them that will have to contend with increasingly terrible handwriting.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse