undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgrogenaut1y ago0 comments

could you provide some examples, code or repos and questions where it does a good job for you (question can also just be completion). Obviously you're having really good experiences with the tools that other aren't having. I'd definitely appreciate that over a lot of assurances taht I'm doing it wrong with my spaghetti code.

0 comments

CuriouslyC1y ago

Try these:

Take a SQL schema, and ask AI to generate crud endpoints for the schema, then sit down and code it by yourself. Then try generating client side actions and state management for those endpoints. Time yourself, and compare how long it takes you. Even if you're fast and you cut and paste from template work and quickly hand edit, the AI will be done and on a smoke break before you're even a quarter of the way through.

Ask the AI to generate correctly typed seed data for your database, using realistic values. Again, the AI will be done long before you.

Try porting a library of helper functions from one language to another. This is another task where AI will win handily

Also, ask AI to write unit tests with mocks for your existing code. It's not amazing at integration tests but with mocks in play it slays.

NoGravitas1y ago

Most of the things you list can be done deterministically, without the risk of AI errors. The first one in particular is just scaffolding that Visual Studio has had for Entity Framework and ASP.NET MVC for a decade now. And if you were using, e.g., LISP, you'd just write a DEFCRUD macro for it once, and re-use it for every similar project.

grogenautOP1y ago

Thank you. That was a lot more informative than the argument you were having. And it's now obvious to me the value you're getting and a few areas that would work for me that I'll try. I'm not slapping out crud apps day to day, but can see how I could accelerate myself.

I appreciate it.

linuxftw1y ago

Your experience mirrors mine. I use ChatGPT or meta for boiler plate code like this. I write golang at my day job, and there's a lot of boiler plat for that language, saves a lot of time, but most importantly, does the tedious boring things I hate doing.

skydhash1y ago

Why does no one uses snippets or create scaffold for projects? My main requirement for a tool is to be deterministic. So that I don't spend time monitoring it as failure is very distinct from success.

Jensson1y ago

Those things are a tiny part of the work though and are all about generating boilerplate code. Tons of boilerplate code isn't the hallmark of a great codebase, I don't think many programmers spends more than 10% of their time writing boilerplate code, unless they work at a very dysfunctional org.

It is true it is faster than humans at some tasks, but the remaining tasks were most of the time, you can't gain more than 11% speedup by speeding up 10% of the work.

grogenautOP1y ago

What's your point? The other person is speeding themself up, and it works for them. What's the appropriate bar for speedups. What would be enough to satisfy you? What problems do you have that AI isn't speeding up that you still feel aren't worth spending your brain on?maybe list them and see if the other people has thoughts on how to go about it?

Things don't move forward by saying it can't be done or belittle others accomplishments.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

CuriouslyC1y ago

Try these:

Ask the AI to generate correctly typed seed data for your database, using realistic values. Again, the AI will be done long before you.

Try porting a library of helper functions from one language to another. This is another task where AI will win handily

Also, ask AI to write unit tests with mocks for your existing code. It's not amazing at integration tests but with mocks in play it slays.

NoGravitas1y ago

grogenautOP1y ago

I appreciate it.

linuxftw1y ago

skydhash1y ago

Jensson1y ago

It is true it is faster than humans at some tasks, but the remaining tasks were most of the time, you can't gain more than 11% speedup by speeding up 10% of the work.

grogenautOP1y ago

Things don't move forward by saying it can't be done or belittle others accomplishments.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse