undefined | Better HN

0 pointsthayne1y ago0 comments

I think it would also include the code used to train it

0 comments

That would be more analogous to the build toolchain than the source code, but yes

Surely traditional “open source” also needs some notion of a reproducible build toolchain, otherwise the source code itself is approximately useless.

Imagine if the source code was in a programming language of which the basic syntax and semantics were known to no one but the original developers.

Or more realistically, I think it’s a major problem if an open source project can only be built by an esoteric process that only the original developers have access to.

pphysch1y ago

Source code in a vacuum is still valuable as a way to deal with missing/inaccurate documentation and diagnose faults and their causes.

Raw training datasets similarly has some value as you can analyze it for different characteristics to understand why the trained model is under/over-representing different concepts.

But yes real FOSS should be "open-build" and allow anyone to build a test-passing artifact from raw source material.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

pphysch1y ago

That would be more analogous to the build toolchain than the source code, but yes

tshaddox1y ago

Surely traditional “open source” also needs some notion of a reproducible build toolchain, otherwise the source code itself is approximately useless.

Imagine if the source code was in a programming language of which the basic syntax and semantics were known to no one but the original developers.

Or more realistically, I think it’s a major problem if an open source project can only be built by an esoteric process that only the original developers have access to.

pphysch1y ago

Source code in a vacuum is still valuable as a way to deal with missing/inaccurate documentation and diagnose faults and their causes.

Raw training datasets similarly has some value as you can analyze it for different characteristics to understand why the trained model is under/over-representing different concepts.

But yes real FOSS should be "open-build" and allow anyone to build a test-passing artifact from raw source material.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse