undefined | Better HN

0 pointsFrostKiwi1y ago0 comments

> Remakes, demakes and remixes of the old days.

You could argue that for multiple genres! Is today's Call of Duty not just a remix of mechanics created decades prior?

Total War, Anno, etc. Highly successful series with new and coming releases with many mechanics evolved and built upon the classic RTS formula.

> As a genre, RTS is dead.

It has shrunken, I would consider it far from dead. There is a limiting factor when we consider the classic RTS formula, it's essentially PC only. Many genres work across consoles as well or were adopted to work there as well. eg. Aim assist in every console FPS. Mobile doesn't work either, touch + classic RTS doesn't mix. RTS has thus a limited audience it can appeal to. But dead it is not, Steam's player counts for Strategy --> Real Time Strategy speak for themselves.

0 comments

hi_dang_1y ago

Shrunken and dead basically mean the same thing here, and again that term shrunken was traditionally used, along with “RTS games are too difficult” and other reasons as to the whys. There is no growth potential and at that point you’re losing players faster than you’re gaining them. It’s a dead genre by all accounts. AoE2 remastered/AoE4 will prop it up in the same way that SC2 propped it up a bit.

Unless I’m wrong it seems like steam thinks dota 2 is an RTS game, which makes any stats around these things very suspicious.

TulliusCicero1y ago

I mean it's definitely a niche, though we're finally seeing indie Starcraft-descended RTSes trying to expand that (there were many other attempts, but generally in other subgenres): Zerospace, Immortal, Stormgate, Battle Aces.

Unfortunately, most of the other attempts to expand the RTS playerbase were incredibly wrong-headed. Almost all of them were obsessed with simplifying the genre to appeal to more people, but in making the game easier to play they also made it less interesting, which is why it's the big traditional RTSes (SC1, SC2, AoE2, AoE4) that have the biggest playerbase, and therefore the most total casual players.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

hi_dang_1y ago

Unless I’m wrong it seems like steam thinks dota 2 is an RTS game, which makes any stats around these things very suspicious.

TulliusCicero1y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse