undefined | Better HN

0 pointsDer_Einzige1y ago0 comments

Not in constitutional law hearings, this is the exact moment when oral arguments are extremely important. They write them down after they're made, not before.

Make better arguments please, you showed you were capable of it earlier when you wrote the top level justification. Why not do it here?

0 comments

remarkEon1y ago

> this is the exact moment when oral arguments are extremely important. They write them down after they're made, not before.

The two parties and their friends have submitted mountains of briefings before oral argument. The arguments made in front of the court are already fully baked. Oral argument is only a signal on where the justices' thinking is taking them at the time. All of this is public, by the way. You can go read everything on your own (something more people in this thread should do).

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsDer_Einzige1y ago0 comments

Not in constitutional law hearings, this is the exact moment when oral arguments are extremely important. They write them down after they're made, not before.

Make better arguments please, you showed you were capable of it earlier when you wrote the top level justification. Why not do it here?

0 comments

remarkEon1y ago

> this is the exact moment when oral arguments are extremely important. They write them down after they're made, not before.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse