Creating a new deployment is just super fast. Developers can deploy their own apps etc.
And then there is Helm.
If we only decide by “need” then most of the time we also wouldn’t need object oriented programming.
Right, who doesn't want to template hundreds of lines of code in a language that uses whitespace for logic and was never made neither for templating nor complex long documents(YAML)? What could possibly go wrong ("error missing xxx at line 728, but it might be a problem elsewhere").
I'd love to have a private pool in my backyard. I don't, even though it's nice to have, because it is too expensive.
We intuitively make cost-benefit choices in our private lives. When it comes to deciding the same things at work, our reasoning often goes haywire.
Sometimes we need an expensive thing to solve a real problem.
Your point about object-oriented programming makes sense. Sometimes, a bash script suffices, and the person who decides to implement that same functionality in Java is just wasting resources.
All of these solutions have a place where they make sense. When they are blindly applied because they're a fad they generate a lot of costs.
Don’t get me wrong, I like K8s and run it at home, and I’d take it any day over ECS or the like at work, but it’s not like you can’t achieve a very similar outcome without it.
Assuming there aren’t any particular scaling or performance requirements, if I were managing something like that, I would almost certainly not use k8s. Maybe systemd on a big box for the services?
Don't get me wrong, maybe they're good choices, but absent any other facts I'd start asking questions about what makes each service necessary.
Some of them try to migrate from it to a unified k8s "platform" (i.e. frequently not pure k8s/EKS/helm but some kind of in-house layer built on top of it). It takes so long that your tenure with the company could end before you see it through.
This way, Azure does most of the heavy lifting you would otherwise have to do yourself, even with managed kubernetes.
In a commercial environment I’d still use kubernetes. But maybe something like k3s or if we are in a cloud environment something like EKS.
Usually with time other services get added to the stack (elastic, grafana, argocd, …)