Why Does Every AI Cycle Start with Chat? (opens in new tab)

(matt-rickard.com)

22 pointshenry_pulver1y ago14 comments

14 comments

Short answer: because chat is a shortcut to anthropomorphization in folks' brains. It's much easier to assign personality and intent to a chat than a floating head that needs to be 99.999% lifelike in order to not feel completely fake.

random_i1y ago

A better answer: natural language is the programming language everyone knows.

onemoresoop1y ago

> A better answer: natural language is the programming language everyone knows.

And when you get into frustrating misunderstanding of details you end up using a programming language anyway. Natural languages are to ambiguous to be useful for specific things. We humans can resolve the ambiguities in our minds, or think we do, based on context. I think the anthropomorphization argument hits closer to home. I feel guilty too of projecting more meaning and intelligence to a generated text and I think I'm not the only one.

1 more reply

AndrewKemendo1y ago

Not an actual pattern

AI cycle in 2012 started with alexnet

AI cycle in 2019 started with Stable Difffusion

rsynnott1y ago

Depends what you mean by 'cycle', I suppose. The current hype-cycle _really_ started with ChatGPT; that was the point where people started getting super-excited and declaring that it would replace all human work by next Thursday.

AndrewKemendo1y ago

What? Diffusion has directly led to industrial artists pushing back against Studios, etc., from utilizing GenAI in their work to displace artists

Yeah, sure a bunch of clowns are talking about how ChatGPT is gonna take over the world meanwhile diffusion is actually making impacts on artists

Again, ChatGPT did not start the hype cycle this time it landed fat in the middle of the GenAI cycle and accelerated it

NBJack1y ago

Chat is perhaps the cheapest implementation you could ever build. It's a linear interaction, easy to test, and arguably the easiest to encode/decode (with a fixed set of inputs too). As an added bonus, it has a familiar, well-understood interface.

wildzzz1y ago

It is now but it hasn't always been easy to make a computer chat naturally like a human without using canned responses. Chess positions are a much easier interface to implement because it's a closed set and very structured (grid position + piece). But humans don't speak in chess moves so it would be difficult for us to speak to an AI that does.

alan-hn1y ago

Exactly. Text is very easy for us to analyze, understand, and compare inputs with outputs

wruza1y ago

Excuse me? A 10x10 plot for an sd lora makes it easy to glance over and see where and how it fails. Good luck glancing at a bunch of text answers.

1 more reply

seadan831y ago

I'm curious about: alpha go, Watson, and the AI that "conquered" chess. Are those outliers, or part of a larger story? It feels to me a contemporary history of AI would mention those milestones.

P_I_Staker1y ago

Every chat begins with a big smile, yet AI has no face. You've been warning. Acts should be in accordenly

porcoda1y ago

Uhm… The boom in AI with LLMs wouldn’t have happened without about a decade of major focus on images (both generative models and DNN models that blew traditional image processing out of the water), and planning/optimization type problems (alpha go, chess, etc.). Seems incorrect to claim that chat starts every cycle.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

14 comments

nameless9121y ago

random_i1y ago

A better answer: natural language is the programming language everyone knows.

onemoresoop1y ago

> A better answer: natural language is the programming language everyone knows.

1 more reply

AndrewKemendo1y ago

Not an actual pattern

AI cycle in 2012 started with alexnet

AI cycle in 2019 started with Stable Difffusion

rsynnott1y ago

AndrewKemendo1y ago

What? Diffusion has directly led to industrial artists pushing back against Studios, etc., from utilizing GenAI in their work to displace artists

Yeah, sure a bunch of clowns are talking about how ChatGPT is gonna take over the world meanwhile diffusion is actually making impacts on artists

Again, ChatGPT did not start the hype cycle this time it landed fat in the middle of the GenAI cycle and accelerated it

NBJack1y ago

wildzzz1y ago

alan-hn1y ago

Exactly. Text is very easy for us to analyze, understand, and compare inputs with outputs

wruza1y ago

Excuse me? A 10x10 plot for an sd lora makes it easy to glance over and see where and how it fails. Good luck glancing at a bunch of text answers.

1 more reply

seadan831y ago

I'm curious about: alpha go, Watson, and the AI that "conquered" chess. Are those outliers, or part of a larger story? It feels to me a contemporary history of AI would mention those milestones.

P_I_Staker1y ago

Every chat begins with a big smile, yet AI has no face. You've been warning. Acts should be in accordenly

porcoda1y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse