undefined | Better HN

0 pointsPostOnce1y ago0 comments

Around here, they're building bigger houses, but also on much smaller plots without gardens or dogs or tree-houses or places for kids to play outdoors.

I suspect it's the same in a lot of places.

Maybe these square-foot-per-person calculations should also include square feet of land.

0 comments

travisb1y ago

If you are going to do that, other play grounds should also be counted: the forests and fields which used to be nearby, the per-child space in nearby parks, etc.

All these are places children used to go unsupervised, but now mostly don't.

Retric1y ago

Most people today don’t want a large back yard.

It’s like an outdoor pool, there’s definitely a market but adding a pool can lower your property’s value. Land doesn’t decrease the value of a property, but it can dramatically lower the number of buyers.

DontchaKnowit1y ago

If this is true, it is so insanely contrary to the opinion of literally every single person I have ever met. Everyone wants a yard. Most people want a sizeable yard for their dogs or kids, or to drink beer and have campfires.

I grew up in rural midwest USA. maybe opinions are different elsewhere, but your comment is a bit baffling. Ive never in my life heard someone say "that house would be perfect if it just came with less land"

Retric1y ago

I know several people who decided to get smaller yards or were happy to move into apartment complexes without them.

We both are dealing with biased samples. A childhood friend who is very into the outdoors moved to a rural area and got 14 acres, everyone else moved to an apartment or a house with under an acre. This stuff shows up on migration patterns, and well there’s a reason the Rural Midwest USA is a small percentage of the US population.

So, I agree many people do want a large yard, but revealed preferences suggest it’s a minority opinion.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

travisb1y ago

If you are going to do that, other play grounds should also be counted: the forests and fields which used to be nearby, the per-child space in nearby parks, etc.

All these are places children used to go unsupervised, but now mostly don't.

Retric1y ago

Most people today don’t want a large back yard.

DontchaKnowit1y ago

Retric1y ago

I know several people who decided to get smaller yards or were happy to move into apartment complexes without them.

So, I agree many people do want a large yard, but revealed preferences suggest it’s a minority opinion.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse