undefined | Better HN

0 pointsyjftsjthsd-h1y ago0 comments

> 1) Socketed chips add significant cost in a number of ways as compared to CoB or just standard soldered chips

Yep, that's probably true.

> 2) This would likely violate most FCC/CE/C-tick/etc. certifications.

IANAL but that doesn't seem like it can possibly be necessarily true, since most computers let you replace the motherboard and wifi card.

> 3) The whole assembly would need to be designed to be field servicable so you could access the circuit boards, which would also add cost (and possible warranty issues).

Not all, but most IoT boxes I've seen already are easy enough to take apart, it's just that there's not much to do with it once it is apart. So I don't think this would be a change.

0 comments

brk1y ago

I'm not saying any of it is impossible, just that it is costly (based on my direct experience at a number of hardware companies).

For an "IoT box" type of product there would likely be fewer issues with the certifications and swapability.

For IoT devices like light switches, bulbs, smart outlets, or anything else where the 120V/240V power is exposed vs. isolated by a power supply (as in the case of a PC or "IoT box") it would likely be too costly to do in a conformant way. Particularly when the tinkerer consumer base that would actually value this is maybe 5% of the total market.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse