undefined | Better HN

0 pointslanfeust62y ago0 comments

> We can just ignore factors if they don't explain everything?

No, we just can't rely on them to explain everything! As you purport.

Only 33% of the homeless suffer from mental illness, and it certainly is not a strong predictor as to why rates are high in some cities but not others. That's the data.

> Affordability is a moot point for people in these categories

It matters to everyone, but even if we pretend it doesn't, that's 67% percent of the homeless.

0 comments

giantg22y ago

"that's 67% percent of the homeless."

The data does not support that. You cannot simply subtract 33 from 100 and claim affordability is the primary factor. Mental illness is not the only factor affecting employability. You have substance abuse, criminal records, etc that all prevent people from finding employment.

slothtrop2y ago

> You have substance abuse, criminal records, etc that all prevent people from finding employment.

Those all respectively represent a small fraction of the whole, and there's usually overlap. You cannot add them all up as though they are completely separate parts of that 100%.

Ultimately affordability is the primary factor, it's indisputable.

giantg22y ago

I'm not saying to ads them up! Please read my comment, as I very clearly stated that there was overlap.

"Ultimately affordability is the primary factor, it's indisputable."

What comprises affordability? It's cost and income. It does not matter what the cost is if you have no income because you have employability issues. Until you fix the employment aspect, the cost aspect is moot.

You can point to a poor quality blog post that doesn't examine all the factors all you want. Perhaps that makes it "indisputable" in your own mind, but thats not going to convince people who want to have real conversation about the root of the issue.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointslanfeust62y ago0 comments

> We can just ignore factors if they don't explain everything?

No, we just can't rely on them to explain everything! As you purport.

Only 33% of the homeless suffer from mental illness, and it certainly is not a strong predictor as to why rates are high in some cities but not others. That's the data.

> Affordability is a moot point for people in these categories

It matters to everyone, but even if we pretend it doesn't, that's 67% percent of the homeless.

0 comments

giantg22y ago

"that's 67% percent of the homeless."

slothtrop2y ago

> You have substance abuse, criminal records, etc that all prevent people from finding employment.

Those all respectively represent a small fraction of the whole, and there's usually overlap. You cannot add them all up as though they are completely separate parts of that 100%.

Ultimately affordability is the primary factor, it's indisputable.

giantg22y ago

I'm not saying to ads them up! Please read my comment, as I very clearly stated that there was overlap.

"Ultimately affordability is the primary factor, it's indisputable."

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse