undefined | Better HN

0 pointsThe_Colonel2y ago0 comments

> Much as Americans might fantasize about adding it as another star to their flag

Bothsidism is a strong in this one. Why am I not surprised it comes from an Austrian?

> If America drops a bomb, it is only because it failed at diplomacy.

First, diplomacy must be backed by strength, leverage, without it there's nothing to negotiate, because the other side can simply take what it wants. As such, sabre rattling is part of diplomacy. Nuclear deterrence is part of diplomacy.

Second, diplomacy may fail. Western diplomacy failed in 1938 and 1939, and there was war. Sometimes such failures happen and you need to be prepared for that. Layered defense.

I'm quite curious what would be your diplomatic solution to the Taiwan problem, hopefully it would respect the wishes of the Taiwanese residents.

0 comments

boffinAudio2y ago

>Austrian

False. I'm Australian. You shouldn't be surprised that someone who has been watching OUR war crimes, crimes against humanity and massive violations of human rights at scale, is critical of the narrative being proffered by folks such as yourself which only leads to more war, bloodshed and calamity. "Bothsidism"?

No, I'm not concerned about any side but my own, which is the only state I can do anything effective about.

>Nuclear deterrence is part of diplomacy.

A classic America-first point of view which is entirely incompatible with the mores of the rest of the world, as we are finding out with BRICS - which is real, true diplomacy.

>Western diplomacy failed in 1938 and 1939

Another very USA'ian-centric perspective which only leads to a blindness. Your argument would be better centered around the failures of the American political ruling classes in preventing the American military junta from massacring 5% of Iraqs population .. in 2003.

Or, lets just address the bear in the room: America's utter failure to commit to the diplomacy of the Minsk accords. Or of the Istanbul agreement. Or any one of countless other acts of real diplomacy that America has shat on, in order to sell its weapons stocks to the cultures its oligarchic classes deem inferior...

Taiwan? Yes indeed, respect the wishes of the Taiwanese residents, and not just the ones the CIA send to have interviews on CNN. ALL of them.

The_ColonelOP2y ago

> False. I'm Australian.

So you're an Australian living in Austria (Vienna, from your github)? Nice!

You're bothsidist, because you're projecting Russian imperialism of trying to conquer Ukraine (for centuries) on USA. Absurd.

> A classic America-first point of view which is entirely incompatible with the mores of the rest of the world, as we are finding out with BRICS - which is real, true diplomacy.

Now it's you making the mistake of assuming an identity.

I hope you're aware of the R in BRICS, currently waging a brutal war and regularly nuclear sabre rattling. So what diplomacy you're talking about?

> America's utter failure to commit to the diplomacy of the Minsk accords.

What did USA had to do with Minsk accords? Also, what a stellar example of diplomacy after Russia invaded Ukraine.

> Taiwan? Yes indeed, respect the wishes of the Taiwanese residents, and not just the ones the CIA send to have interviews on CNN. ALL of them.

You can take a look at the election results in the recent years (there were presidential ones just a month ago). Or are those manipulated by CIA as well?

boffinAudio2y ago

As a non-Russian citizen, I can do nothing effective about Russia - AND NEITHER CAN YOU AMERICAN.

>What did USA had to do with Minsk accords?

They instructed their puppet to ignore them and knowingly set Ukraine on a path to utter destruction as a result.

>Also, what a stellar example of diplomacy after Russia invaded Ukraine.

There was none - that is the point.

khokhol2y ago

American military junta massacring 5% of Iraqs population in 2003.

Even outside estimates of total "excess deaths" in the entire Iraq war -- regardless of cause or party directly responsible -- don't amount to 5 percent of the population. Or even half that.

In other words -- just another random factoid you vaguely thought you remembered from somewhere. As with your synopsis of Minsk + Istanbul.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

boffinAudio2y ago

>Austrian

No, I'm not concerned about any side but my own, which is the only state I can do anything effective about.

>Nuclear deterrence is part of diplomacy.

A classic America-first point of view which is entirely incompatible with the mores of the rest of the world, as we are finding out with BRICS - which is real, true diplomacy.

>Western diplomacy failed in 1938 and 1939

Taiwan? Yes indeed, respect the wishes of the Taiwanese residents, and not just the ones the CIA send to have interviews on CNN. ALL of them.

The_ColonelOP2y ago

> False. I'm Australian.

So you're an Australian living in Austria (Vienna, from your github)? Nice!

You're bothsidist, because you're projecting Russian imperialism of trying to conquer Ukraine (for centuries) on USA. Absurd.

> A classic America-first point of view which is entirely incompatible with the mores of the rest of the world, as we are finding out with BRICS - which is real, true diplomacy.

Now it's you making the mistake of assuming an identity.

I hope you're aware of the R in BRICS, currently waging a brutal war and regularly nuclear sabre rattling. So what diplomacy you're talking about?

> America's utter failure to commit to the diplomacy of the Minsk accords.

What did USA had to do with Minsk accords? Also, what a stellar example of diplomacy after Russia invaded Ukraine.

> Taiwan? Yes indeed, respect the wishes of the Taiwanese residents, and not just the ones the CIA send to have interviews on CNN. ALL of them.

You can take a look at the election results in the recent years (there were presidential ones just a month ago). Or are those manipulated by CIA as well?

boffinAudio2y ago

As a non-Russian citizen, I can do nothing effective about Russia - AND NEITHER CAN YOU AMERICAN.

>What did USA had to do with Minsk accords?

They instructed their puppet to ignore them and knowingly set Ukraine on a path to utter destruction as a result.

>Also, what a stellar example of diplomacy after Russia invaded Ukraine.

There was none - that is the point.

khokhol2y ago

American military junta massacring 5% of Iraqs population in 2003.

Even outside estimates of total "excess deaths" in the entire Iraq war -- regardless of cause or party directly responsible -- don't amount to 5 percent of the population. Or even half that.

In other words -- just another random factoid you vaguely thought you remembered from somewhere. As with your synopsis of Minsk + Istanbul.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse