undefined | Better HN

0 pointsfilleduchaos2y ago0 comments

So...it's scarce?

I genuinely don't understand what the point of bringing up copyright here is. Apart from a tiny handful of materials, even physical products rely on legal protections against counterfeits and knockoffs to be scarce. Why do we talk about software as if it's the first and only thing to be artificially scarce?

0 comments

thayne2y ago

No it isn't scarce. There isn't a limited supply. There is no point at which the software company would say "sorry, we're out of stock". Unless maybe you are selling physical media with the software on it. With SaaS, possibly you are constrained by the capacity of your infrastructure, but that isn't usually a practical concern unless you have incredibly unexpected growth.

bruce5112y ago

Well, for closed-source software there's a scarcity of suppliers, not supply.

The value is not in "a copy of windows" it's that all copies of windows come from one supplier.

Yes there can be competing products, that achieve the same goals, or there may be scarcity there too.

Of course, even when achieving the same goals, some products are more desirable than others. There's no scarcity of OS options, but some would seem to be more popular.

thayne2y ago

"a copy of windows" is what you pay for (well, what you pay for a license to use). And there isn't a scarcity of copies of windows.

davidw2y ago

It has had artificial scarcity introduced to provide an incentive to create it. It's certainly an imperfect system in many ways, but it kinda sort does create scarcity that drives revenue which pays programmers to keep working on the software.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

thayne2y ago

bruce5112y ago

Well, for closed-source software there's a scarcity of suppliers, not supply.

The value is not in "a copy of windows" it's that all copies of windows come from one supplier.

Yes there can be competing products, that achieve the same goals, or there may be scarcity there too.

Of course, even when achieving the same goals, some products are more desirable than others. There's no scarcity of OS options, but some would seem to be more popular.

thayne2y ago

"a copy of windows" is what you pay for (well, what you pay for a license to use). And there isn't a scarcity of copies of windows.

davidw2y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse