undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbenrutter2y ago0 comments

I wonder if its because we're sometimes talking cross purposes.

For me, coding is almost exclusively using python libraries like numpy to call out to other languages like c or FORTRAN. It feels silly to say I'm not coding in Python to me.

On the other hand, if you're writing those libraries, coding to you is mostly writing FORTRAN and c optimizations. It probably feels silly to say you're coding in Python just because that's where your code is called from.

0 comments

zare_st2y ago

There is a version of BASIC, a QuickBasic clone called Qb64 that is lightning fast because it transpiles to C++. By your admission a programmer should think that BASIC is fast because he only does BASIC and does not care about the environment details?

It's actually the opposite, a Python programmer should know how to offload most, or use the libraries that do so, out of Python into C. He should not be oblivious to the fact that any decent Python performance is due to shrinking down the ratio of actual Python instructions vs native instructions.

benrutterOP2y ago

I think maybe it's just semantics as long as everyone agrees where the speedup is happening (at the low level language calls).

I noticed that you're pretty hard in the "basic isn't fast, the thing it transpiles to is fast" camp, but still accidentally said "there is a version of BASIC [...] that is lightning fast" which I'm not sure you think? Highlights just how tricky it is to talk about where speed lives

zare_st2y ago

I agree with that.

There is clear distinction between original language design (an interpreter) and a project aiming to recreate a sub-standard of that language and support its legacy codebase via a transpiler.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsbenrutter2y ago0 comments

I wonder if its because we're sometimes talking cross purposes.

For me, coding is almost exclusively using python libraries like numpy to call out to other languages like c or FORTRAN. It feels silly to say I'm not coding in Python to me.

0 comments

zare_st2y ago

benrutterOP2y ago

I think maybe it's just semantics as long as everyone agrees where the speedup is happening (at the low level language calls).

zare_st2y ago

I agree with that.

There is clear distinction between original language design (an interpreter) and a project aiming to recreate a sub-standard of that language and support its legacy codebase via a transpiler.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse