undefined | Better HN

0 pointsa13692099932y ago0 comments

Yes. Do this (make sure it's not a top-level submission) and cite the HN comment specifically. Stupid rules deserve stupid compliance.

0 comments

Why would a top-level submission not be valid on Wikipedia?

It (presumably) would; the problem is that it could be considered more dignified and academically respectable than a random forum comment.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsa13692099932y ago0 comments

Yes. Do this (make sure it's not a top-level submission) and cite the HN comment specifically. Stupid rules deserve stupid compliance.

Why would a top-level submission not be valid on Wikipedia?

It (presumably) would; the problem is that it could be considered more dignified and academically respectable than a random forum comment.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse