undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgruez2y ago0 comments

That still sounds suspect. Surely there are areas that don't have 3g coverage? For instance, underground parking garages or rural areas (especially in western US). These aren't common use cases, but common enough that they surely would have garnered press/media attention back when 3G was working. I vaguely remember a story about how a rental car was trapped in an underground garage because it couldn't get the unlock code. Why are we only hearing about it now? Moreover, surely those incidents would have caused them to fix the issue?

0 comments

5 comments · 1 top-level

vanilla_nut2y ago· 4 in thread

I own a Subaru Crosstrek from this same era, it definitely has the Starlink bits in the cockpit ceiling.

There must be more to this story. I've parked that car in an underground parking garage with absolutely no signal on any carrier for at least 2 weeks straight (likely more) with no issue. I've parked it for days at trailheads and wild camping spots around the High Rockies where there's also no signal.

I 100% believe that the Starlink module is poorly programmed, reliant on false assumptions of 3G always existing, and capable of draining the battery. But I would really love to know why that's never happened to me.

avianlyric2y ago

It could be that the modem can still see the phone tower, but its handshake to create a 3G connection fails, which it then retries indefinitely.

That would be different to having no signal whatsoever, where modem wakes up, listens for a tower, concludes there’s nothing there and goes back to sleep again.

That would explain why this issue is only cropping up now that 3G is being turned off, and how this scenario was missed by engineers. They assumed there was either a tower they could communicate with, or nothing. They didn’t account for a perfectly good tower being available, advertising itself as a recognisable network, but refusing to handshake.

siftrics2y ago

I feel like this is it. I camped hundreds of days in areas with no service for miles and never had this problem. My battery ended up dying in my driveway in town.

mikeocool2y ago

I’m in the same boat, the one time I had issues with the battery on my 2020 crosstrek was when I accidentally left the dome light on for a week. Looking at the class action lawsuit seemingly related to this: https://www.subarubatterysettlement.com/ looks like the Crosstrek and Impreza aren’t included in the class.

Perhaps they are not impacted for some reason.

siftrics2y ago

I can back this up. I regularly go car camping in the middle of nowhere in the Rockies. Absolutely no service for miles.

I hadn't gone camping for ~4-5 weeks, but still drove my car every day. Suddenly had the battery issue, pulled the plug, and the issue is gone.

I don't really know how to debug this. Something recently changed, but I don't know what. You'd think my battery would've died during all the time that I was out of service.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

5 comments · 1 top-level

vanilla_nut2y ago· 4 in thread

I own a Subaru Crosstrek from this same era, it definitely has the Starlink bits in the cockpit ceiling.

avianlyric2y ago

It could be that the modem can still see the phone tower, but its handshake to create a 3G connection fails, which it then retries indefinitely.

That would be different to having no signal whatsoever, where modem wakes up, listens for a tower, concludes there’s nothing there and goes back to sleep again.

siftrics2y ago

I feel like this is it. I camped hundreds of days in areas with no service for miles and never had this problem. My battery ended up dying in my driveway in town.

mikeocool2y ago

Perhaps they are not impacted for some reason.

siftrics2y ago

I can back this up. I regularly go car camping in the middle of nowhere in the Rockies. Absolutely no service for miles.

I hadn't gone camping for ~4-5 weeks, but still drove my car every day. Suddenly had the battery issue, pulled the plug, and the issue is gone.

I don't really know how to debug this. Something recently changed, but I don't know what. You'd think my battery would've died during all the time that I was out of service.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse