undefined | Better HN

0 pointsploum2y ago0 comments

Exactly. Is it your business to track people?

There’s 90% chance that no, it’s not your business. There’s also a lot of chances that your website is about a product. In which case, it doesn’t make sense to know how many people come and read. People only need the information to know "will I buy that or not?" or, even more frequently "I’ve bought that but I don’t understand something".

Tracking is counterproductive in most scenarios. (but very few understand that)

0 comments

YetAnotherNick2y ago

Europe's parliament website[1] uses cookie banner, even though its job is literally to just show information. If they want to track visitors any non trivial site would.

[1]: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/portal/en

ploumOP2y ago

Which demonstrates exactly my point: web dev are now incapable of not tracking users even if it’s actually harming their business.

I had an experience with a national meteo application including facebook trackers. I complained and they replied that they were totally unaware of that fact. The tracking was added by default by the contractor as part of his standard template. (note: they removed the tracking after my complain).

But it is also about people in charge, who are completely addicts to statistics about the number of visitors and all information. People like to track others. They actually want that.

The sad part is that nobody in IT really complain nor tell them that it is creepy. We install blockers on our own computers and get over it, writing code that track those without blockers without batting an eye.

starbugs2y ago

> The sad part is that nobody in IT really complain nor tell them that it is creepy.

Which may be because if you do, you will typically be called the "technical person" who "doesn't understand anything about 'normal' users" and you should be more focused on your actual technical tasks.

Sorry for being cynical. I couldn't resist.

viraptor2y ago

You don't need cookies for it, but it very much makes a difference how many people come and read. Optimising the visitor-to-buyer pipeline is an important job for retail. To even begin doing that, you need to know what percentage of visitors bought something.

carlosjobim2y ago

> you need to know what percentage of visitors bought something.

Why? What will you improve by knowing that, and why couldn't you improve that without knowing it?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse