undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmulmen2y ago0 comments

How do you write the time? Do you put seconds or minutes before hours? Why not?

How do you write the year? Do you put decade before century?

How do you write numbers? Do you put the ones place before the tens?

Toddmorey asked why units don’t go from small to large and I explained that it is inconsistent with how we write numbers.

Thus, there’s no logical reason to do anything other than large to small. Anything other than ISO 8601 is preferred only for familiarity and no such inconsistent format is inherently more correct or logical.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

bearmode2y ago· 1 in thread

>How do you write the time? Do you put seconds or minutes before hours? Why not?

No, because the seconds are rarely important.

>How do you write the year? Do you put decade before century?

No, because that's not how numbers work.

>How do you write numbers? Do you put the ones place before the tens?

Same answer.

>Toddmorey asked why units don’t go from small to large and I explained that it is inconsistent with how we write numbers.

Dates aren't numbers. There is a lot more context and meaning around dates that we need to consider when we verbalise and write them. But, for the purposes of e.g. data storage then absolutely - we can consider them no different from numbers. You have to understand that isn't the case with conversational English, though.

mulmenOP2y ago

> You have to understand that isn't the case with conversational English, though.

Yes, conversational english is arbitrary. The preference there is the familiar so the listener understands. But both commonly used date formats (MM/DD/YYYY HH:MI:SS and DD/MM/YYYY HH:MI:SS) are inconsistent and arbitrary. You can’t say one makes more sense than the other because that’s just a matter of personal familiarity.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse