undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbarbs2y ago0 comments

> Kind of like one way sharing? You give, they take?

Yes. There are plenty of examples of people sharing knowledge on the internet without expecting anything in return. Wikipedia, StackOverflow, and most open-source projects come to mind.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

logifail2y ago· 1 in thread

> people sharing knowledge on the internet without expecting anything in return

Imagine: creative person shares their output with friendly-apparently-non-profit website X, then behind the scenes company Y scrapes and uses it, then sells a closed-source product based on it to Big Corps Z1 - Z100.

Y and Z both get rich. The original creator? Gets nothing, and they may not even know what's happened.

Maybe I'm getting too old for this, but "sharing knowledge on the internet" isn't what it used to be. Neither are licence agreements :/

dspillett2y ago

This is exactly what it used to be. Check the history of IMDB for the best known example. We are just more aware of the issue these days because of cases like that in the past.

At least on this occasion the site is explicit about a licince it expects user submitted content to be covered by rather than the user just assuming (unless they've not bothered to check).

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse