undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgrncdr2y ago0 comments

Sure, I’m not trying to make the argument of the OP, just clarify it because I do think it warrants consideration.

Regarding the role of shame in the rise of fascism (and the NSDAP). I agree it played a role, but I would characterize that as an (all too successful) exploit of human psychology.

My opinion is that “shame” as a basic human emotion does perform an important function in our social fabric, and trying to inoculate ourselves against it en masse is not without its downsides.

0 comments

goodpoint2y ago

You opinion goes against modern science: psychology, pedagogy and sociology agree that positive feedback is much more effective than negative and it's healthier in the long run.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsgrncdr2y ago0 comments

Sure, I’m not trying to make the argument of the OP, just clarify it because I do think it warrants consideration.

Regarding the role of shame in the rise of fascism (and the NSDAP). I agree it played a role, but I would characterize that as an (all too successful) exploit of human psychology.

My opinion is that “shame” as a basic human emotion does perform an important function in our social fabric, and trying to inoculate ourselves against it en masse is not without its downsides.

0 comments

goodpoint2y ago

You opinion goes against modern science: psychology, pedagogy and sociology agree that positive feedback is much more effective than negative and it's healthier in the long run.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse