You are moving the goalposts here. The original claim I am responding to is "A tool that gives incorrect and inconsistent results shouldn’t have any part of a decision making process."

I agree that there are places where we shouldn't put AI and that checking whether something is an LLM or not is one of them. However I think the sentence above takes it way too far and breast cancer screening is a pretty clear example of somewhere we should accept AI even if it can sometimes make mistakes.