undefined | Better HN

0 pointshotdogscout2y ago0 comments

I am aware of it. Same can be said for political correctness or autogynephilia or meta attraction.

They are terms used as an implication for right wing conspiracy theories but also do in part describe undeniable real behaviours and dogmas on the left.

Some leftists do think black people should be excused to violate whites, trans people should be excused to violate cis people, etc.

Nietzsche's view of Jewish morality as a vindictive passive aggressive reaction to impotence towards Roman oppression is accurate. It obviously does not describe all of the Jewish faith but it's very hard to hypothesize a different reason for "giving the other face" being their moral reaction towards violence. This critique is at the heart of the Black Panther movement (according to Huey P Newton's intentions). https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/026327641774134...

Yes, it was used by Nazis as one of the reasons for the Holocaust, doesn't mean the hypothesis is wrong.

Just like autogynephilia is used as a reason to deny trans people of transitioning treatment. Yes it is a true phenomenon, there are many self described autogynephiles claiming that is their sexual experience, doesn't mean trans people should be denied their autonomy for it.

If someone decides to kill everyone who can't run a given velocity the act of measuring running speed shouldn't implicate genocide forever.

0 comments

unford2y ago

> Just like autogynephilia is used as a reason to deny trans people of transitioning treatment. Yes it is a true phenomenon, there are many self described autogynephiles claiming that is their sexual experience, doesn't mean trans people should be denied their autonomy for it.

Maybe there are psychological benefits to treating these males with hormones and surgery, so they can fulfil their overwhelming fetish.

However, the fact that it is a sexual fetish, for most of these males who desire to be women, is a very good reason to deny them access to women-only spaces, despite their insistence. Not many actual women want to deal with boundary violation of these men imposing themselves where they're not wanted.

hotdogscoutOP2y ago

I don't think there's data showing it's a fetish for most trans women, you'd need polling on that. If we assume the hypothesis it's a fetish I would still support people in indulging in said fetish.

I don't think the state shouldn't allow someone to identify as whatever they want as there should be equality in the law in the first place according to the liberal democratic values I have.

I don't think women should have the right to segregate spaces based on femaleness any more than males do. Feminists fought for this for some hundred years and closed many male centric spaces in the process, how come now it's unfair? They're both unfair, either abolish single sex spaces or let's discuss how unequal some demands of feminism are.

If we segregate sexes to prevent sexual crimes why not segregate every other section of people to prevent every other type of crime?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse