undefined | Better HN

0 pointsstefncb2y ago0 comments

I don't know C#, but I'll take a guess:

I think it's exactly the same issue as null in Lisp and Lua — you sometimes want to differentiate between null as in "I returned no value", and null as in "I returned the fact that there is no value". Or null vs false vs empty list in the context of Lisp.

This distinction becomes very clear (and sometimes very annoying) when you realize that in Lua, setting a table key to null completely removes it, so there's no way to store the concept of a missing value unless you define a special value (like DBNull). A slot being null literally signifies its absence.

0 comments

kazinator2y ago

There is no difference between "no value" and "the fact that there is no value". "The fact that" is just rhetorical verbiage.

There is an ambiguity in a polymorphic container between a present entry indicating a null value, and a null return indicating there is no entry.

E.g. hash table being used to represent global variables. We'd like to diagnose it when a nonexistent variable is accessed, while allowing access to variables that exist, but have a null value.

This is because the variables are polymorphic and can hold anything.

When we are dealing with a typed situation (all entries are expected to be of a certain type, and null is not a member of that type's domain) then there is no ambiguity: if a null appears in the search for a value that must be a string, it doesn't matter whether "not found" is being represented by an explicit entry with a null value, or absence of an entry.

tedunangst2y ago

This rhetorical verbiage matters a lot in a language like Lua where you can pack an array full of dbnull sentinel types but filling it with nil results in an empty array.

recursive2y ago

I don't know lua. But the behavior you describe seems like a quirk of lua tables. Instead of having `table.get(key)` return a sentinel value, you can replace it with `table.has_key(key)` and `table.get(key)`.

I'm not sure about the ergonomics of the trade in lua. But in C# the ergonomics of `DBNull` are terrible. If it were just replaced with `null` everywhere, everything would just be better.

IMHO.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse