Would I like it that my phone detects tampering and hardware integrity violation and spams me with alerts? Absolutely.
Would I support some way of being able to repair my phone with legal genuine parts though? Totally.
Are those exclusive options? I don't know. Which one I think is more important? I don't know.
> Are those exclusive options? I don't know. Which one I think is more important? I don't know.
First they are indeed not exclusive options, locking parts when the phone is locked is a possible option.
And then we have to think what's the most common for most people, a dropped iPhone on the floor which needs a component change or somebody swapping touchid while you are sleeping. I have my own idea on that.
What if a genuine part is modified. I am not sure it is a solvable problem?
> First they are indeed not exclusive options, locking parts when the phone is locked is a possible option.
If that is technically possible I am all for it (but if I had to choose between no integrity protection and integrity protection that makes it harder to repair, I don't know what I would choose). However if you are a phone, how would you distinguish between a legitimate repair and malicious swapping out of parts? Sounds like incompleteness theorem would say you can't
The reason Apple prompts for genuine parts is to devalue the stolen phone market. If repair shops could put in any old camera, there would be a lot more incentive to sell stolen phones to repair shops, therefore more incentive to steal phones, therefore more stolen phones.
Apple's a giant company. I have no emotional connection to them. But most of what we're talking about here makes sense from a business and even customer-friendly perspective, or at least as a reasonable tradeoff between ease/expense of repair and likelihood of having your phone stolen or pwned.
For stolen parts, they could lock the parts if the device is locked, that's a solution against theft to resell parts but again, that's not what's being done either. It's becoming pretty hard to justify their bad practices.
