It sure doesn't seem like any of these would apply (there are no installs, popups, or ads). Can you drop a screenshot of the "sign in with google" page (which has been taken down) to see if it looks flaggable to folks?
Here is a screenshot. https://ibb.co/c8vQjwv
For 3 days everyone that visited ANY page in our whole domain was given a notice that we were being deceptive and attempting to steal their personal information and were practicing social engineering. This kind of thing that would cause a person's own mother to question their integrity.
We were never able to communicate with a person at Google. Never received an explanation of the cause. A Bot or AI tried and convicted us, and enacted our punishment. And that is the world we live in today. We still do not know what we did wrong. So now, what step do we take?