Sorry this is complete BS. Inflation makes the dollar more useful for exchange. Not only that, the dollar is great for consumer goods as it is pegged to a basket of them unlike Bitcoin. Then on top of that, the liquidity available for trading and moving USD across markets is at least 2 orders of magnitude greater than BTC.
I sold all my btc a long time ago for better cryptocurrencies, and the price appreciation of those relative to Bitcoin proves the point further.
They are, however, a nearly perfect vehicle for scams and fraud. =)
You want something that holds 1-to-1 exchange through time for it to be useful for exchange. E.g. stock market appreciate versus goods, and dollar depreciates. You want something that's actually stable.
2. Just because there's more liquidity available, does not the dollar have better monetary properties than Bitcoin. I think the author is talking about monetary in the terms of monetary policy of the dollar versus Bitcoin.
3. I don't see how Bitcoin's appreciation versus other cryptocurrencies prove any point.
There’s three issues. First, 1-1 to what? For daily expenses, people want their currency to be stable against consumer goods in a practical way. Second, price inflation doesn’t matter if it’s a small enough that day to day prices don’t change significantly. Third, for a variety of complex macroeconomic factors, the economy runs more efficiently with slight inflation - for instance, it automatically reduces the price of goods that have sticky prices such as wages which reduces unemployment.
> liquidity isn’t an important monetary property
Ok you can define what is “money” however you like, but the fact is that a currency is more useful the easier it is to trade it. The more goods you can buy with it, and the less the market moves when you make a large purchase, the more useful the currency is. In fact this is one of the few areas where Bitcoin has value versus other cryptocurrencies.
> price appreciation doesn’t matter
It proves that the people who said alt coins are scams are silly. Alt coins have value that is increasing faster than Bitcoin. You might disagree with how they generate value or whether they are valuable to you personally, but that doesn’t change the fact that well designed alt coins have outperformed Bitcoin.
Bitcoin can be the best technical alternative for money, which I believe it currently is, but if people in general do not believe it is money then it simply is not money. But in fact, the bar is even lower than that for Bitcoin (or any alternative money's failure) - if the government(s) decide that you cannot accept Bitcoin (or any money) easily in trade, then it loses dominance as money (and thus is not really).
When people say Bitcoin is not backed by anything, the intuition they are trying to communicate is that Bitcoin's value relies on people believing and accepting that value (of course so does the US Dollar, but look who is in the ring fighting for it).
What people truly want out of a crypto-currency is value which is more objective, which is not reliant on the belief of others; it is the difference between a monetary chain, like Bitcoin, and a commodity chain.
https://mukdde.substack.com/p/a-monetary-blockchain-is-less-...
The difference is that, if you earn something valuable that is not US Dollars (e.g., Bitcoin), the US Government (the most powerful organization in the history of civilization) will tax you on it in US Dollars, and project global power towards collecting it. The reverse is not true.
The “credibility” of the US Dollar, or any government-backed currency, has a lot to do with the amount of power that government has.
If, in America, an American citizen has a bunch of USD stolen from them, they can go to the government. In an ideal world, the government will find the thieves, get the money back, and dole out justice.
If that same person gets Bitcoin stolen from them, there’s nothing they can do.
Similarly, if the USD starts to lose its value, you can bet the government will do everything in its power to stop it from losing value. The US government has a lot of power to make changes that will actually effect this change, too, such as raising interest rates to fend off high inflation.
If the value of Bitcoin starts deflating, however, no one can really do anything.
So yes, sure, in a philosophical, pedantic way, Bitcoin is backed by something. But it’s worse than any major currency. In fact, it’s worse than the worst stock, because if market sentiment changes, there’s quite literally nothing _else_ propping up its value.
It's become a way for people to manage their anxiety around the state of the economy, pumping money into Bitcoin whenever it looks shiny relative to the fiat currency, and getting out when it doesn't, or when it stops going up (no more shiny attraction.) You need a sustained campaign of lies and deception to keep polishing that turd, so to speak.
We're better off without it, but you can't take away some people's psychological safety blankie.
Crypto has demonstrated an unbelievable ability to survive repeated failures, debunking, scams, fraud, and even government bans. What other technology has failed to deliver on any of its promised benefits for over a decade and survive in "any day now" mode for so many people? What other technology has enabled so much fraud and financial ruin and evaded regulation for this long. As a meme crypto shows more tenacity than COVID does as a virus.
it's literally just a variable in a config file lmao
This seems false to me. I can tap a piece of plastic to pay for all kinds of things and then pay that off in turn with a few clicks on a web site. And it's all pretty secure and safe and has well established rules for when things go wrong that do a pretty good job of protecting me.
Not sure if that was the point he was trying to make.
Bitcoin is backed by greater fools trying to pump the price up and other fools trying to buy into the pyramid scheme.
But seriously it is backed by entirely nothing but speculation.
History will not be kind to Bitcoin and its delusional supporters. It will definitively and inevitably end up on the scrap heap of other failed experiments and bubbles like Tulip Mania and Beanie Babies.
For a more intellectual deconstruction of web3, bitcoin and all other crypto arguments this is a fantastic resource debunking every point on crypto:
https://web3.lifeitself.org/guide#claim-bitcoin-will-and-sho...
