Ask HN: What technologies would you use today to build an API business?

2 pointssomeuser545413y ago5 comments

I've built a few APIs, primarily using either Node.js with the Express framework or Rails in the API configuration.

They've both worked, but Node.js often feel "unwieldy" very quickly, while Rails often seems like way to much magic and rigidness.

I'm about to start working on a new project and wondering if it's worth trying something else. I have a lot of experience with Kotlin, so thought about ktor. I also keep hearing good things about Go.

So, what is your opinion? What would you use?

5 comments

CharlieDigital3y ago

If you've done Node.js with TypeScript (or even JS), you may want to consider C# and .NET Web APIs. C# and TS are syntactically similar.

.NET minimal web APIs are very similar to Express in setup (at least initially; you layer in middleware as needed).

You can get an API up and running in Google Cloud pretty quickly.

Short video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlnEm7JyvyY (< 7 minutes to get a minimal web API into Google Cloud Run with no special tooling involved).

Entity Framework (ORM) is pretty good and supports a variety of databases (SQL Server, Postgres, MySQL, others). Working with JSON is low-friction.

someuser54541OP3y ago

How would you compare C# and .NET Web APIs with Entity Framework to Rails and Active Record?

CharlieDigital3y ago

Very similar at the entity level, but C#'s LINQ interface to the generate the query is unique as you get fully typed queries in C# that are translated to the underlying DB.

So example:

    database
        .Users
        .Where(u => u.ActivatedUtc < ...) // Filter
        .Select(u => new {...}) // Project

dev-screen3y ago

There is no "best" technology. I'd suggest going with the framework or language that you are most comfortable with. That could be node.js. It wouldn't be my first choice, but it could be the right one for you.

One word of advice, as I noticed you use the word "magic" when referring to rails. I did the same earlier in my career, turns out it was just that I didn't understand it well enough yet. That takes time, unfortunately! It's only after you spend hours or days tracking down a tricky bug that you begin to get into the internals of these systems and begin to understand the "magic".

someuser54541OP3y ago

It's been awhile since I've built an API with Rails or Express, so I'd be learning them again anyway.

What would be your "first" choice?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

Ask HN: What technologies would you use today to build an API business?

2 pointssomeuser545413y ago5 comments

I've built a few APIs, primarily using either Node.js with the Express framework or Rails in the API configuration.

They've both worked, but Node.js often feel "unwieldy" very quickly, while Rails often seems like way to much magic and rigidness.

I'm about to start working on a new project and wondering if it's worth trying something else. I have a lot of experience with Kotlin, so thought about ktor. I also keep hearing good things about Go.

So, what is your opinion? What would you use?

5 comments

CharlieDigital3y ago

If you've done Node.js with TypeScript (or even JS), you may want to consider C# and .NET Web APIs. C# and TS are syntactically similar.

.NET minimal web APIs are very similar to Express in setup (at least initially; you layer in middleware as needed).

You can get an API up and running in Google Cloud pretty quickly.

Short video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlnEm7JyvyY (< 7 minutes to get a minimal web API into Google Cloud Run with no special tooling involved).

Entity Framework (ORM) is pretty good and supports a variety of databases (SQL Server, Postgres, MySQL, others). Working with JSON is low-friction.

someuser54541OP3y ago

How would you compare C# and .NET Web APIs with Entity Framework to Rails and Active Record?

CharlieDigital3y ago

Very similar at the entity level, but C#'s LINQ interface to the generate the query is unique as you get fully typed queries in C# that are translated to the underlying DB.

So example:

    database
        .Users
        .Where(u => u.ActivatedUtc < ...) // Filter
        .Select(u => new {...}) // Project

dev-screen3y ago

someuser54541OP3y ago

It's been awhile since I've built an API with Rails or Express, so I'd be learning them again anyway.

What would be your "first" choice?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse