undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrnk3y ago0 comments

When we can upload our brains to the cloud, and you can do something with them like interacting or running the brain, then we'll all be effectively immortal. That's a pretty big deal. See the book altered carbon.

0 comments

12 comments · 2 top-level

ProjectArcturis3y ago· 6 in thread

They wouldn't be us. We will still die when our bodies fail. But maybe there will be some AI tricking our friends and family into thinking we're still there.

rnkOP3y ago

You are making a claim that is theological, religious, and scientific. Yes, our form of life on earth ends when our bodies die today. But what is the essence of us, no one really knows. Various people claim it's locked into your body, or you have some kind of soul that depends on your body. Or your brain is just running a program and the information and mechanism dies when your body dies. I lean toward the last category, but no one knows.

The body is constantly changing. We already know about physical and chemical abnormalities in the way your body works affects your "person" and we can sometimes address them with surgery or drugs. The physical body's limits impact the observed brain. If uploading is possible, if there are some examples of working cases, if I don't hurt anyone why not try it?

shaky-carrousel3y ago

If you have a stroke, and survive, you won't be you anymore.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

Yeah by the same logic we die every night when we sleep.

mlyle3y ago

What if it's an incremental upload? E.g. we start with some prosthetics and slowly migrate organic function to digital?

Is this the Ship of Theseus, or is it a slow but nonobvious death?

sumtechguy3y ago

The Ship of Theseus is a weird one too. If you take a car apart and replace it piece by piece and replace the whole car you kind of have the same car. But what if you kept all the old pieces and put them back together? Which one is the original car? It is a interesting thought sub experiment that plays on the 'Ship of Theseus'. You could end up with the same issue here. If I make a perfect copy of myself, who is the 'real' me? There is an obvious 'older' me but the other one is just as capable as I am.

speed_spread3y ago

If you keep the original bioware fully operational, it's more like an incremental fork running on an emulator. You can start having conversations with your approximated self.

EamonnMR3y ago· 4 in thread

Immortal as long as someone's paying to run the instance.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

You'll have tiered processing, just like today. You can slum it out with limited simulation capabilities, or if you have a job you can afford the premium processor hours.

webmaven3y ago

See the Amazon Prime series "Upload" (two seasons so far).

Rather funny, BTW, compared to most works around a similar premise.

rvba3y ago

I bet soon after the first few people are made immortal this way, one of them will hack the banks, or the stock market, or countless other organizations.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

And then you'd have the first court case and prison sentence for a non-human consciousness.

Which is just one step closer to the simulated hell for uploaded consciousnesses that get naughty, from Surface Detail by Ian Banks.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

12 comments · 2 top-level

ProjectArcturis3y ago· 6 in thread

They wouldn't be us. We will still die when our bodies fail. But maybe there will be some AI tricking our friends and family into thinking we're still there.

rnkOP3y ago

shaky-carrousel3y ago

If you have a stroke, and survive, you won't be you anymore.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

Yeah by the same logic we die every night when we sleep.

mlyle3y ago

What if it's an incremental upload? E.g. we start with some prosthetics and slowly migrate organic function to digital?

Is this the Ship of Theseus, or is it a slow but nonobvious death?

sumtechguy3y ago

speed_spread3y ago

If you keep the original bioware fully operational, it's more like an incremental fork running on an emulator. You can start having conversations with your approximated self.

EamonnMR3y ago· 4 in thread

Immortal as long as someone's paying to run the instance.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

You'll have tiered processing, just like today. You can slum it out with limited simulation capabilities, or if you have a job you can afford the premium processor hours.

webmaven3y ago

See the Amazon Prime series "Upload" (two seasons so far).

Rather funny, BTW, compared to most works around a similar premise.

rvba3y ago

I bet soon after the first few people are made immortal this way, one of them will hack the banks, or the stock market, or countless other organizations.

minsc_and_boo3y ago

And then you'd have the first court case and prison sentence for a non-human consciousness.

Which is just one step closer to the simulated hell for uploaded consciousnesses that get naughty, from Surface Detail by Ian Banks.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse