undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbitwize3y ago0 comments

It's not political. Which programs to allocate the government budget to is political. This is a human rights issue. Extensive research has been done into the relationship between the physical, psychological, and social aspects of sex and gender, and the definitions we use today reflect our current understanding of how these interact, acknowledging that some people's psychological and social selves may not correspond with their physical biology. Refusal to acknowledge these people's lived experience is pigheaded ignorance and rank bigotry.

0 comments

leereeves3y ago

I agree it's a human rights issue, but it's a very complicated one, and trans rights conflict with other human rights. Sometimes biology matters.

Allowing biological females to participate in separate sports without biological males, for example. Where do you stand on that? Don't you agree that biology (like testosterone level) matters sometimes?

Or in dating, do you think people have the right to want to know the biological sex of someone they date?

I acknowledge the lived experience of trans people but I don't think their desires outweigh the interests of all other people.

And of course, balancing those competing interests is absolutely political. It's just dishonest to claim this isn't political.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse