undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbumby3y ago0 comments

Where do you think the OP was being criticizing? I did not see them say anyone was wrong, or making bad decisions. They even made sure to equivocate by saying there's nothing wrong with trying to change one's circumstances.

0 comments

lapcat3y ago

I'm talking about your comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34408305

bumbyOP3y ago

So your issue is with me pointing out that saying what amounts to "Nothing you say can change my mind" isn't conducive to conversation?

How would you say the OP adds to the discussion if what they say, almost by definition, is meant to shut down discussion? Or is your issue with pointing out HN guidelines? It feels like you're reading way more into my point than was actually there if you think I was criticizing anything related to their life decisions.

It's fine with me if someone has that point of view. But I don't think a forum like HN, which is supposed to be about fostering dialogue, is the best place to share it, or at least share it in that manner.

lapcat3y ago

> So your issue is with me pointing out that saying what amounts to "Nothing you say can change my mind" isn't conducive to conversation?

I've already explained this: "It's supposed to be about intellectual curiosity. Not questioning other people's life choices and giving unsolicited advice."

You've actually warped the direct quote "No one is going to talk me into BEING [emphasis mine] otherwise" into "Nothing you say can CHANGE MY MIND". The OP is talking about how they feel, what kind of person they are, what kind of life they intend to life. Not talking about some kind of belief about a subject X.

This conversation with you is becoming very tedious, and I'm repeating myself, so I doubt that I'll be continuing.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

lapcat3y ago

I'm talking about your comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34408305

bumbyOP3y ago

So your issue is with me pointing out that saying what amounts to "Nothing you say can change my mind" isn't conducive to conversation?

lapcat3y ago

> So your issue is with me pointing out that saying what amounts to "Nothing you say can change my mind" isn't conducive to conversation?

I've already explained this: "It's supposed to be about intellectual curiosity. Not questioning other people's life choices and giving unsolicited advice."

This conversation with you is becoming very tedious, and I'm repeating myself, so I doubt that I'll be continuing.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse