You aren’t going to have poles or hanging lights on a runway.
It is embedded lights.
That have to work without fail in extreme temps, all weathers, with planes rolling over them all day.
They have to have certain visibility at different angles, they have to fail gracefully.
These things are rarely ‘that’s just…’
Honeywell et al all have huge catalogues with all kinds of aerodrome lights. Here's Hughey & Phillips: https://www.hugheyandphillips.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06...
As you can see, embedded lights are also represented from pg 23 onwards and red "stop bar" lights can be found on pg 38. Here's a picture of them installed: https://i.imgur.com/ThNIQaw.jpg
This compliant seems to me akin to me not backing up my computer's internal drive to this external drive I have sitting on my desk, until I can make a little RAIDed setup to address the small probability that the backup drive will fail. Having no backup at all is worse than requiring a high standard to the point that the backup may not be implemented.
It's not like if they break, nobody will notice. Install them, have a process to verify they're working regularly, fix them if they break. Any downtime whilst they're being fixed is just as risky as every day the project is delayed to to this high standard of reliability.
If even one indecent like this happens hundreds of people die in a horrible all consuming fire, travel for the entire seaboard would be halted, hundreds of thousands of passenger would be dealt with for not being where they are supposed to be, and that's before the extraordinarily expensive repair to the tarmac and the scrapping of the planes. There is, quite literally, zero margin of error.
99% is absolutely reasonable for one layer of defense among many! That is one of the best methods to achieve truly high reliability, as is needed in this case: stack many reliable systems in such a way that they all must fail to get an overall failure. It is not perfect, of course, and things can always cascade, but it is a powerful technique.
So it’s very strange you’re passionately arguing to keep the riskier current setup that almost had a massive accident — rather than improve it.
Perfect is the enemy of better.
The first gas turbine was invented in 1791
Are they cheap? Can you buy them for next day delivery?
Yes. They are consumables comparable to bulbs and light fixtures at home, just good LEDs on a PCB in a metal/plastic case. It's sheer insanity to pretent that aerodrome lights are some magic technology.
Seems like most of those problems would be more caused by the power cables than the light itself.
