undefined | Better HN

0 pointsMa8ee3y ago0 comments

Uh, no.

You haven't passed on any genes until you have fertil offspring. Being born is of course necessary, but far from sufficient.

0 comments

Broken_Hippo3y ago

That's not true. If you have offspring, they have some of your genes. They don't have to be fertile.

For a better example, take humans: If you have a child and they grow up to be infertile, you have still passed on your genes. If they choose not to have children - even if fertile - you've still passed on your genes. Your particular mix of genes just won't live on in subsequent generations. Grandchildren aren't a requirement for you to simply pass on genes.

bearmode3y ago

I think we all know they're talking on an evolutionary level here, not just individuals...

carlmr3y ago

You shouldn't "Uh, no" people if you're just 50% correct some of the time.

1 more reply

Ma8eeOP3y ago

If your children are infertile, you are from an evolutionary perspective a dead end.

tremon3y ago

You being born is the ultimate proof of genes having been passed on. In what way is that not sufficient?

Ma8eeOP3y ago

But you haven't passed on any genes. You have only been passed genes.

That is, if the choice of language confuses people: You have only been given those genes. You haven't given any genes to anyone else who can give those genes further, which is what matters in an evolutionary perspective.

tremon3y ago

And your parents passing on their genes to you doesn't matter, from an evolutionary perspective? You have only "been given" those genes, as if by magic?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

Broken_Hippo3y ago

That's not true. If you have offspring, they have some of your genes. They don't have to be fertile.

bearmode3y ago

I think we all know they're talking on an evolutionary level here, not just individuals...

carlmr3y ago

You shouldn't "Uh, no" people if you're just 50% correct some of the time.

1 more reply

Ma8eeOP3y ago

If your children are infertile, you are from an evolutionary perspective a dead end.

tremon3y ago

You being born is the ultimate proof of genes having been passed on. In what way is that not sufficient?

Ma8eeOP3y ago

But you haven't passed on any genes. You have only been passed genes.

tremon3y ago

And your parents passing on their genes to you doesn't matter, from an evolutionary perspective? You have only "been given" those genes, as if by magic?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse