undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrvieira3y ago0 comments

(Not an economist by any measure) Can you explain "tax cuts which will have a big inflationary impact". The 20% bracket went down to 19%. The 45% bracket disappeared (now included in the 40%) which is only for £150k+ earners, which is a tiny minority in the UK. I don't think the actual numbers move inflation.

Isn't it more the conflicting policies (BoE and gov) in theory and the perception of them not being in the same page?

0 comments

colinmhayes3y ago

Increasing the money supply causes inflation. Rich people don't just put their money under their mattress. They invest it which means it's being given to other people who use it to buy things.

rvieiraOP3y ago

I understand why that might cause inflation. The projected cost is £55b, is this really enough to put the country in an inflationary meltdown?

IMHO the problem is that none of these measures actually guarantee (or even promote) economic growth and the realisation that the UK has economic illiterate leaders it's what's freaking the markets.

psd13y ago

To be more precise, the market has realised that the economic illiteracy of our leaders is worse than previously feared.

And I use "leaders" with scornful irony

klyrs3y ago

> They invest it which means it's being given to other people who use it to buy things.

Now do real estate investing.

colinmhayes3y ago

Real estate investing means either paying people to build things for you, or paying people for something that's already built. Obviously building things causes inflation as you compete for commodities required to build, but buying already built real estate also means the seller now has money that they invest and that will eventually get consumed too.

mbrodersen3y ago

Or the invested money will simply drive up share prices without giving anybody else money to buy things.

origin_path3y ago

Yeah, the idea it's the tax cut isn't correct. That's not even a big tax cut. It's the energy price cap that utterly dominates. The left will insist otherwise because they hate tax cuts and love price controls, but that doesn't make it accurate.

adammarples3y ago

The carnage happened at 9.30 am on Friday directly after the budget announcement, caused by the budget announcement. Energy subsidy was proposed earlier in the week. The market suddenly realised that kwasi and liz are irresponsible idealists and acted accordingly.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

colinmhayes3y ago

Increasing the money supply causes inflation. Rich people don't just put their money under their mattress. They invest it which means it's being given to other people who use it to buy things.

rvieiraOP3y ago

I understand why that might cause inflation. The projected cost is £55b, is this really enough to put the country in an inflationary meltdown?

IMHO the problem is that none of these measures actually guarantee (or even promote) economic growth and the realisation that the UK has economic illiterate leaders it's what's freaking the markets.

psd13y ago

To be more precise, the market has realised that the economic illiteracy of our leaders is worse than previously feared.

And I use "leaders" with scornful irony

klyrs3y ago

> They invest it which means it's being given to other people who use it to buy things.

Now do real estate investing.

colinmhayes3y ago

mbrodersen3y ago

Or the invested money will simply drive up share prices without giving anybody else money to buy things.

origin_path3y ago

adammarples3y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse