undefined | Better HN

0 pointsActorNightly3y ago0 comments

To just arbitrarily redefine autopilot for cars as something that can avoid accidents isn't a good argument. You are supposed to still have awareness when using autopilot in an airplane, ship - paying attention to things like radar, radio, ADSB, e.t.c. And in a Tesla, you are supposed to pay attention visually.

Full self driving is still in beta test, with present dangers that you have to accept.

All the accidents that happen with Tesla autopilot use are driver error, full stop. Just like its driver error to get drunk and drive, or be looking down at a phone distracted, and rear end a motorcycle. As someone who rides, Id rather have roads full of Teslas with FSD, because for every time it fucks up there are vastly more times for it to avoid an accident, given that you are not going to get rid of drunk, high, or distracted drivers.

0 comments

Ekaros3y ago

I think we could make argument that autopilot is a unfit system for car travel.

Both air and water the distances and reaction times needed are much much longer. At least in the situations autopilots are used. And they are not really used in situations where manual control is needed.

Gordonjcp3y ago

I've never seen Tesla's "autopilot" avoid an accident that a human driver wouldn't have reacted to sooner. Maybe the standard of driving in the US is very low, or something.

herewulf3y ago

It actually is. Some states are far worse than others. In my state, a learning permit can be obtained at the age of 15. Not exactly a good age for handling grave responsibility.

Gordonjcp3y ago

I mean I grew up in a part of the world where if you can't drive and maintain a tractor and a fair selection of implements at the age of 12 they start phoning special schools and highly qualified educational psychologists, but I get that this is very much the exception. It's weird like that even down south here at 56°N.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsActorNightly3y ago0 comments

Full self driving is still in beta test, with present dangers that you have to accept.

0 comments

Ekaros3y ago

I think we could make argument that autopilot is a unfit system for car travel.

Gordonjcp3y ago

I've never seen Tesla's "autopilot" avoid an accident that a human driver wouldn't have reacted to sooner. Maybe the standard of driving in the US is very low, or something.

herewulf3y ago

It actually is. Some states are far worse than others. In my state, a learning permit can be obtained at the age of 15. Not exactly a good age for handling grave responsibility.

Gordonjcp3y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse