undefined | Better HN

0 pointsto-too-two3y ago0 comments

There's a few private/third-party sties that serve as a marketplace for paid Godot assets.

0 comments

It seems unlikely that'll ever be as useful to people as an official store would be.

I think people that spend enough time to learn to use a game engine will go to the trouble of finding the best site / source for assets. Unity and Unreal both have good sites for this, but that's partly because it is there business model. Godot is just not as much of a business. It seems like the two great potential business (attention HN types :) ) are: - asset / plugin library stores - simple libraries / frameworks for console ports that are not open source / or a port service.

TulliusCicero3y ago

> Godot is just not as much of a business.

Well, maybe it should be. I don't think anyone would begrudge the Godot team taking a small percentage as part of running an asset store, and that means more people who can work on Godot full-time, in addition to the convenience of the asset store itself.

I wouldn't want Godot to go full blown for-profit public corporation, but having more full-timers and more of a real business model like some other open source foundations sounds good to me.

ttymck3y ago

Why is that? (I'm not too familiar with Godot or the unity asset store)

TulliusCicero3y ago

Convenience/discoverability, the lack of which results in less people using it, and less people using it means you don't get critical mass.

The important thing here is the network effects, not whether you personally can find some store somewhere that technically fits the bill.

to-too-twoOP3y ago

Mostly trust. Finding it. Usually lacks the polish and presentation an official asset store would have.

Unity's asset store is pretty top-notch and is a good one to compare other asset stores too. Unreal Engine's marketplace pales in comparison.

Link: https://assetstore.unity.com/

to-too-twoOP3y ago

Agreed for the most part, although there is the possibility of one being really polished and catching on.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

TulliusCicero3y ago

It seems unlikely that'll ever be as useful to people as an official store would be.

georgeecollins3y ago

TulliusCicero3y ago

> Godot is just not as much of a business.

I wouldn't want Godot to go full blown for-profit public corporation, but having more full-timers and more of a real business model like some other open source foundations sounds good to me.

ttymck3y ago

Why is that? (I'm not too familiar with Godot or the unity asset store)

TulliusCicero3y ago

Convenience/discoverability, the lack of which results in less people using it, and less people using it means you don't get critical mass.

The important thing here is the network effects, not whether you personally can find some store somewhere that technically fits the bill.

to-too-twoOP3y ago

Mostly trust. Finding it. Usually lacks the polish and presentation an official asset store would have.

Unity's asset store is pretty top-notch and is a good one to compare other asset stores too. Unreal Engine's marketplace pales in comparison.

Link: https://assetstore.unity.com/

to-too-twoOP3y ago

Agreed for the most part, although there is the possibility of one being really polished and catching on.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse