undefined | Better HN

0 pointsarethuza3y ago0 comments

We've had 3 DSG cars between us - no problems so far. Mind you, they were under warranty and we get them regularly serviced.

My current car is a 1l 3-cylinder DSG Kamiq - which I am pretty happy with. Only complaint being the slow starting touch screen and the move away from physical buttons (e.g. for heated windscreen).

0 comments

21433y ago

Wow that's pretty cool.

Over here it's only a matter of time before DSG inevitably fails.

Apparently, it tends to overheat when idling in traffic in D. This is also a problem in VW cars which uses the same gearbox.

It's a really hot climate where I live; I wonder if that's a factor.

The good thing is that Skoda/VW don't hesitate before replacing a failed gearbox (and then that one fails).

It's a lovely gearbox when it works.

arethuzaOP3y ago

"it tends to overheat"

I'm in Scotland, so it rarely gets above 20C and it quite often fairly damp - which presumably keeps the gearbox nice and cool :-)

Edit: We also very rarely sit in traffic, which might help as well.

21433y ago

Still, other gearboxes work well here. So maybe there's a design fault somewhere.

There's a Wikipedia entry for DSG problems: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-shift_gearbox#Problem...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsarethuza3y ago0 comments

We've had 3 DSG cars between us - no problems so far. Mind you, they were under warranty and we get them regularly serviced.

My current car is a 1l 3-cylinder DSG Kamiq - which I am pretty happy with. Only complaint being the slow starting touch screen and the move away from physical buttons (e.g. for heated windscreen).

0 comments

21433y ago

Wow that's pretty cool.

Over here it's only a matter of time before DSG inevitably fails.

Apparently, it tends to overheat when idling in traffic in D. This is also a problem in VW cars which uses the same gearbox.

It's a really hot climate where I live; I wonder if that's a factor.

The good thing is that Skoda/VW don't hesitate before replacing a failed gearbox (and then that one fails).

It's a lovely gearbox when it works.

arethuzaOP3y ago

"it tends to overheat"

I'm in Scotland, so it rarely gets above 20C and it quite often fairly damp - which presumably keeps the gearbox nice and cool :-)

Edit: We also very rarely sit in traffic, which might help as well.

21433y ago

Still, other gearboxes work well here. So maybe there's a design fault somewhere.

There's a Wikipedia entry for DSG problems: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-shift_gearbox#Problem...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse