Well, if the price is the same, that hardly matters? Or are you implying unpaid/illicit downloads will be worse with a legal digital version as opposed to an illicitly scanned copy?
After buying an e-reader I can't defend buying print books from an environmental standpoint - it may be a sunk cost/resources fallacy - but with all the infrastructure for digital production, distribution and reading in place - print copies are a strict waste of resources.
Reading print is still a much more enjoyable experience (except in the tub -- a waterproof Kindle is still great and lightweight for that!), especially with the slow speed of e-ink screens.
I can't defend ebooks compared to the reading, sharing, and the later selling at a used book store my cast-off print books.
I've even gotten O'Reilly books from a decade ago at used book stores that are great to read and look great on my shelf, and I love finding some old novel by some forgotten author instead of whatever the latest Amazon bestseller is.
And I don't have to worry about the Orwellian deletion of my books from my e-reader: https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18am...
You don't 'waste' electricity, you waste your money. And in many places electricity is (much) cheaper than (good) paper.
>toxic materials used to produce a e-reader.
Surely you realise that different chemicals are used during paper production too? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_sulfide and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_hydroxide for example. And this depends on paper type too.
>Reading print is still a much more enjoyable experience
And this is entirely subjective.
>I can't defend ebooks compared to the reading, sharing, and the later selling
While I 100% agree with selling option, sharing is at least as easy with epub. Unless we are talking about a book from Amazon or something. In most cases you can just send a file over your preferred messenger.
As for the deletion I'm with you. That's why I always buy DRM free, or promptly crack anything I buy.
This is generally true for ebooks as well, as I only have electric heating. Both probably require more electricity for lighting anyway.
> and the toxic materials used to produce a e-reader.
I assume an ebook reader uses more resources to produce than a book, but 1) I already have a reader, and 2) I have for example e-books I inherited from my dad - that's approximately a thousand books. Even just moving them into my apartment would require non-trivial resources.
> Reading print is still a much more enjoyable experience
I don't really agree. Especially not for technical books.
> I can't defend ebooks compared to the reading, sharing, and the later selling at a used book store my cast-off print books.
Agree that the Kindle/Amazon drm/marketplace is pretty bad. Not all books have draconic drm, though - and in such cases it's much easier to share a book with a friend that has moved over seas for example.
> I've even gotten O'Reilly books from a decade ago at used book stores that are great to read and look great on my shelf,
Sure, but in the event this is a problem - it's also a drm problem, not a problem inherent to ebooks.
As for books about "programing language x version y, with best practices as of year z" - I fully expect them to be mostly outdated after 5 to 10 years - maybe replaced by a new version.
> and I love finding some old novel by some forgotten author instead of whatever the latest Amazon bestseller is.
I've never discovered books from the AZ bestseller lists, but I've bought a few classics.
There are always going to be books that are hard to get - like the excellent:
Howard McCord book: "The Man Who Walked to The Moon" which was self-published if I'm not mistaken. I found it in a thrift store in Berlin. As it happens, it's now available for the Kindle:
https://www.amazon.com/Man-Who-Walked-Moon-Novella/dp/092970...
> And I don't have to worry about the Orwellian deletion of my books from my e-reader
Again - a market/drm problem (and a real one for sure).
I really do hope we will see more diversity in ebook sales, sharing, re-sale and lending.