Your graph appears to show Samsung overtaking RIM and Nokia in profits and moving into second place as its smartphone marketshare grows to be the largest (it overtook them both in marketshare during the last year).

Do you think that supports your point or mine? As a reminder my point was that "I'm equally confident that their profits from smartphones are large and growing quickly".

(The bubbles' seem to paint the same picture in a more dynamic way, with Apple, Samsung and HTC rising strongly over the last year though it ends at June.)

I'm a bit confused about Apple's profit being "6" according to the bubble thing in June and it being $7.5 Billion for their entire product line the next quarter. I guess that's not just smartphones then (edit: yep, confirmed it's all products combined).