undefined | Better HN

0 pointslawnchair_larry14y ago0 comments

> Take it from someone who knows: how good you are at your job matters very, very little in comparison with how much people like you as a person.

I think this is untrue simply because smart people who are good at their job are very likeable in general. Who doesn't like the smart productive guy? Conversely, who can stand the dumb guy on the team who never does any work? Of course there are exceptions, but my experience is that the social structure among nerds is largely a meritocracy. Just don't be mean to people.

If this hasn't been your experience, I think you had some misfortune by ending up in companies where politics dominate. There are both. Look at upper management - are they technically smart, or charismatic? Whichever one they are is likely what will have propagated throughout the company. Also watch out for mediocrity, that propagates too.

Of course, I'm referring to technical jobs, not business in general. If it were MBA, I'd agree with you.

0 comments

3 comments · 2 top-level

palish14y ago· 1 in thread

> If this hasn't been your experience, I think you had some misfortune by ending up in companies where politics dominate.

Fliko14y ago

I totally agree with being social at college, and being really friendly and helpful to everyone, but doing good in your studies is pretty much a guaranteed way to become good at grinding your way through things that are perhaps very boring. They are both equally important and unless you are working, you should be able to find time for both activities. Studying with classmates is also a good way to do both.

EDIT: I don't know what I replied to this comment and not your main comment about socializing at school, but w/e

rayiner14y ago

> I think this is untrue simply because smart people who are good at their job are very likeable in general. Who doesn't like the smart productive guy? Conversely, who can stand the dumb guy on the team who never does any work?

I think in practice if you're in the middle 80% of the productivity spectrum, how well you interact with other people matters more than your technical ability.

You're not always just interfacing with other nerds. And in a startup context, as a founder you'll spend as much time talking to MBA types as you will on technical details.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse