undefined | Better HN

0 pointschriscjcj4y ago0 comments

Very interesting! Thank you! I did a little looking and found this FWIW...

I noticed in OP's post that the two frequencies for the cowbell are 540hz and 800hz (although I don't see where this is denoted on the original schematics.) But we'll assume they're accurate numbers.

While a perfect fifth is a difference of 7 semitones, this produces a difference of only 6.804 semitones. It would seem that its designers didn't have a perfect fifth in mind.

Also, 540Hz is C#5 -45 cents and 800Hz is G5 +35 cents. So neither note seems intended to correspond to any natural key.

0 comments

6 comments · 3 top-level

smoyer4y ago· 2 in thread

In the original circuit,the same RC network is used for both the attack and decay so that circuit will indeed produce a 1:1 mark:space ratio.

JKCalhoun4y ago

Curious about the term "1:1 mark:space ratio" since it was also in the article. I would have used the term "50% duty cycle".

smoyer4y ago

I purposely repeated the OP's wording but since we're talking about an astable multivibrator,frequency and duty cycle (in percent) makes sense. I did a lot of circuit design for communications systems and I associate the words mark and space with ones and zeroes in a frame/word.

1 more reply

dahart4y ago· 1 in thread

> While a perfect fifth is a difference of 7 semitones, this produces a difference of only 6.804 semitones. It would seem that its designers didn't have a perfect fifth in mind.

Remember that 7 semitones is not a perfect fifth. (Note this depends on your definition of perfect fifth, some people allow for being close, since equal temperament is so common.)

While a perfect fifth is a 3:2 ratio of frequency, seven semitones isn’t exactly 1.5, it’s more like 1.498.

800/540 is ~ 1.48, so I definitely agree the designers weren’t going for a fifth, very likely they wanted some beat interference to give it a nice metallic warble.

chriscjcjOP4y ago

You are correct sir.

I was speaking (a bit erroneously) in the context of an equal tempered scale. (I think.)

Indeed, the natural overtone series is the proper context for a true perfect fifth.

max-m4y ago

One of the diagrams shows the frequencies as 1.85ms and 1.25ms, 540.5 and 800 Hz respectively.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse