You are both right. The Fed has its public mandates (which it uses the coarse tool of interest rates to manage), but also protects US commercial banks through their refusal to issue narrow bank licenses and their refusal to issue a CBDC or FedAccounts without being shoved by the legislative and executive branches (just like they dragged their feet on FedNow until Congress lit a fire under them because Zelle, owned by the largest banks, was acting anti competitively with smaller community banks).

Lots of Fed criticism to go around for everyone’s enjoyment.