undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrad_gruchalski4y ago0 comments

We use a custom elastic storage on steroids with Keycloak integration for enabling multi-tenancy in Jaeger so we can do SLA tracking and reporting. So the answer is yes.

I get your point about contributing, especially features that are incompatible with the maintainer vision. Feature creep, right?

What I value in open source projects is extensibility. Plugins which one can maintain outside of the main product.

> "But" do you need another storage? :)

I’m only saying that it’s possible. I might not need it but if someone does and they want to self host it as a managed solution, it can be done right in Jaeger.

> Which tools / features do you have in mind?

The default Jaeger UI isn’t really ergonomic. Trace info is more useful in the context of other information. As in, tools pulling trace info out of storage and overlaying on other data. There’s also Grafana Tempo.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

vmihailenco4y ago· 1 in thread

Thanks for the answer - that all makes sense... "but" :) there is also some sense in NOT having to support different storages / plugins API and instead supporting more features that work out of the box. At least I hope so.

I will try Grafana Tempo & Loki - thanks for reminding. It is just that all their products look the same like the "original" Grafana for metrics which TBH does not look especially ergonomic too... Somehow Jaeger still comes first when people talk about tracing.

rad_gruchalskiOP4y ago

> there is also some sense in NOT having to support different storages / plugins API and instead supporting more features that work out of the box

I humbly do not agree. There’s always going to be an edge case which your features aren’t going to support and having the ability to roll out a plugin is the fastest way to integrate. There are also features I may want to keep confidential/proprietary depending on who the client is. In some cases even the existence of a certain feature in a certain shape gives away what a client is doing.

I’m generally staying away from software without extensibility opportunities. These types of solutions almost always end up as part of a larger infrastructure so extensibility is important.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse