An Introduction to Tensor Calculus (opens in new tab)

(grinfeld.org)

65 pointswoggy4y ago14 comments

14 comments

14 comments · 7 top-level

paulpauper4y ago· 5 in thread

I dunno why there is so much interest in this subject. Just knowing basic calculus and linear algebra will cover the majority of applications. Why does the chapter on matrix multiplication come 7 chapters after "The Christoffel Symbol". I think there are better guides than this, shorter and more to the point and better organized. Start with Cartesian tensors and polar coordinate transforms.

dataflow4y ago

> Just knowing basic calculus and linear algebra will cover the majority of applications.

I'm confused by your comment. It's a book on tensor calculus, not a book on linear algebra or calculus (or a book on machine learning), right? It's like seeing a book on calculus and complaining linear algebra is sufficient. Or seeing a book on linear algebra and complaining matrix multiplication is sufficient. The text isn't teaching how to massage N-dimensional NumPy arrays, it's teaching the algebra surrounding an object.

tomatocracy4y ago

It always used to be the case that the main reason people learned tensor calculus was General Relativity (as well as some other bits of theoretical physics). I know machine learning is a popular and growing field, but I suspect theoretical physics remains the main reason people learn it.

jfoutz4y ago

because machine learning is finding and descending the steepest gradient in lots of dimensions.

paulpauper4y ago

you don't need curved cordinates or covariant derivatives for that

brianpan4y ago

> I think there are better guides than this

Care to share?

addcninblue4y ago· 1 in thread

It would be cool to have some kind of PDF export! Definitely seems very educational nevertheless.

woggyOP4y ago

Supporters do get access to PDFs of his draft books. These are rewrites of his original book on tensor calculus [1]. I worked through most of the original and I thought it was quite good.

[1] https://www.amazon.com.au/Introduction-Tensor-Analysis-Calcu...

canjobear4y ago· 1 in thread

The content seems good but it's hard to get used to the pompous style.

pavelgr4y ago

Author here. I'd love for you to give me some details of what you mean so I can improve my book before I send it to the printers.

woggyOP4y ago

Pavel Grinfield is writing a number of tensor textbooks that he is self-publishing. They can be found for free on his website [1]. He also has Youtube channel with some great videos. I just started supporting him on Patreon as I think he has a really great teaching style.

I have no relationship to Pavel and just want to support his efforts.

[1] https://grinfeld.org/

chadcmulligan4y ago

I have his book and others relating to tensor analysis and its good as is his YouTube channel, if anyone is after a gentler introduction to differential geometry I've recently discovered this book "Curvature of Space and Time, with an Introduction to Geometric Analysis" by Iva Stavrov. It glosses over and leaves out a lot of the proofs and topology discussions etc and gives a good overview to get started.

Edit: a link https://smile.amazon.com/Curvature-Introduction-Geometric-An...

chunky19944y ago

Pretty nice overview, I'd highly recommend Hartl's gravity for a physics focused introduction to tensor calculus along with an actual application centric usage of the same: https://www.amazon.com/Gravity-Introduction-Einsteins-Genera...

ngcc_hk4y ago

Need more examples in the beginning of why tensors. The Euler example is good but not clear. But overall at least the introduction is good.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

14 comments

14 comments · 7 top-level

paulpauper4y ago· 5 in thread

dataflow4y ago

> Just knowing basic calculus and linear algebra will cover the majority of applications.

tomatocracy4y ago

jfoutz4y ago

because machine learning is finding and descending the steepest gradient in lots of dimensions.

paulpauper4y ago

you don't need curved cordinates or covariant derivatives for that

brianpan4y ago

> I think there are better guides than this

Care to share?

addcninblue4y ago· 1 in thread

It would be cool to have some kind of PDF export! Definitely seems very educational nevertheless.

woggyOP4y ago

Supporters do get access to PDFs of his draft books. These are rewrites of his original book on tensor calculus [1]. I worked through most of the original and I thought it was quite good.

[1] https://www.amazon.com.au/Introduction-Tensor-Analysis-Calcu...

canjobear4y ago· 1 in thread

The content seems good but it's hard to get used to the pompous style.

pavelgr4y ago

Author here. I'd love for you to give me some details of what you mean so I can improve my book before I send it to the printers.

woggyOP4y ago

I have no relationship to Pavel and just want to support his efforts.

[1] https://grinfeld.org/

chadcmulligan4y ago

Edit: a link https://smile.amazon.com/Curvature-Introduction-Geometric-An...

chunky19944y ago

ngcc_hk4y ago

Need more examples in the beginning of why tensors. The Euler example is good but not clear. But overall at least the introduction is good.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse