undefined | Better HN

0 pointspaulddraper4y ago0 comments

> just demonstrates that the git interface is horribly broken

This is HN criticism #94238 on the terrible git CLI.

Okay, sure.

Would you kindly post your superior git CLI? Or at least the outline of it?

---

Snark aside, Git's popularity is not an accident. Bitbucket supported Mercurial too.

0 comments

seoaeu4y ago

> Would you kindly post your superior git CLI? Or at least the outline of it?

You are literally replying to a comment that describes a possible better CLI for git...

kjeetgill4y ago

I suspect it was added in an edit in response to this comment. Dad is downvoted!

Certhas4y ago

Actually no. I didn't edit the original post... shrugs

avip4y ago

git has quite an inconsistent cli, this is well covered in "master git". And yes, I said it without proposing a better one.

paulddraperOP4y ago

"master git" This is a great demonstration of git's inconsistencies.

I maintain git stacks up well against other similarly mature/complex software (Nginx, AWS, Java), but it's a wonderful read nonetheless.

(And holy hell what a hard thing to search for...can't find the link.)

avip4y ago

https://stevelosh.com/blog/2013/04/git-koans/

The trick is to remember it's called "git koans"

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointspaulddraper4y ago0 comments

> just demonstrates that the git interface is horribly broken

This is HN criticism #94238 on the terrible git CLI.

Okay, sure.

Would you kindly post your superior git CLI? Or at least the outline of it?

---

Snark aside, Git's popularity is not an accident. Bitbucket supported Mercurial too.

0 comments

seoaeu4y ago

> Would you kindly post your superior git CLI? Or at least the outline of it?

You are literally replying to a comment that describes a possible better CLI for git...

kjeetgill4y ago

I suspect it was added in an edit in response to this comment. Dad is downvoted!

Certhas4y ago

Actually no. I didn't edit the original post... shrugs

avip4y ago

git has quite an inconsistent cli, this is well covered in "master git". And yes, I said it without proposing a better one.

paulddraperOP4y ago

"master git" This is a great demonstration of git's inconsistencies.

I maintain git stacks up well against other similarly mature/complex software (Nginx, AWS, Java), but it's a wonderful read nonetheless.

(And holy hell what a hard thing to search for...can't find the link.)

avip4y ago

https://stevelosh.com/blog/2013/04/git-koans/

The trick is to remember it's called "git koans"

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse