undefined | Better HN

story

0 pointsnarag4y ago0 comments

The threshold is very low.

Well, not low enough for me. After a few attempts to answer some questions early on, I gave up. Read only for me. I don't even remember what the problem was.

Why making contributing difficult and consuming easy? I guess it worked for them. Counterintuitive, but nice jackpot.

0 comments

manigandham4y ago

Because contributing has no value unless your contribution is actually good, and often there's a lot of crap that's negative value because it's wrong or off-topic or spam.

Having a barrier greatly helps overall quality.

naragOP4y ago

Having a barrier helps manageability of the site, so from a business' perspective it's been good, indeed.

jfoster4y ago

Don't forget that a site being able to be managed & stay in business is also good for users.

1 more reply

CRConrad4y ago

So downvote the contributions, then -- but you can't do that if they can't be made in the first place! Read-only site for me too.

Then again, same stupid "earn points before you can post" system here on HN too.

bhandziuk4y ago

As far as I can remember it's always been this way: very low barrier to entry. All you have to do is make an account to ask and answer questions.

I don't know why you had a hard time posting. Maybe you're thinking of commenting?

The counter is ExpertsExchange: very difficult to do both.

naragOP4y ago

No idea, but I was just trying to answer some questions. I remember vaguely that I needed some points to help and I needed to help to get the points, so... I shrugged and let it be.

wizzwizz44y ago

If a question is very popular, a lot of people think it's like a normal forum and post “me too” answers. (Or, at least, they used to, before everyone knew Stack Overflow.) So there's a mechanism to “protect” questions so you need at least 10 rep (on that site – the “you contributed lots on another site so probably aren't a spammer” bonus doesn't count) before you can answer.

Very few questions are protected.

MrFantastic4y ago

The first post on SO for most accounts tend to be from Newbs. The people see the question and think Read The Fucking Manual and downvote. Then you have zero karma and you can't do anything else.

The problem is that the Newb doesn't even know where to start in the manual.

mkoryak4y ago

If you want, I'll give you some points by making a bounty on some old question and giving it to you. You have to answer it though.

naragOP4y ago

Thank you, but this was never something that I wanted to do for my own interest.

I just saw someone with an unsolved problem and found out that I'd had to go through loops to help, so I gave up.

Actually it seems that owners became rich and it's now a popular site without my help, so I guess it can still survive without me :)

joe4633694y ago

As helpful as you no doubt would be, until you interact with SO in some way you're indistinguishable from a misleading moron.

naragOP4y ago

That wasn't a problem in any of the other forums I've contributed to. Go figure!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

manigandham4y ago

Because contributing has no value unless your contribution is actually good, and often there's a lot of crap that's negative value because it's wrong or off-topic or spam.

Having a barrier greatly helps overall quality.

naragOP4y ago

Having a barrier helps manageability of the site, so from a business' perspective it's been good, indeed.

jfoster4y ago

Don't forget that a site being able to be managed & stay in business is also good for users.

1 more reply

CRConrad4y ago

So downvote the contributions, then -- but you can't do that if they can't be made in the first place! Read-only site for me too.

Then again, same stupid "earn points before you can post" system here on HN too.

bhandziuk4y ago

As far as I can remember it's always been this way: very low barrier to entry. All you have to do is make an account to ask and answer questions.

I don't know why you had a hard time posting. Maybe you're thinking of commenting?

The counter is ExpertsExchange: very difficult to do both.

naragOP4y ago

No idea, but I was just trying to answer some questions. I remember vaguely that I needed some points to help and I needed to help to get the points, so... I shrugged and let it be.

wizzwizz44y ago

Very few questions are protected.

MrFantastic4y ago

The first post on SO for most accounts tend to be from Newbs. The people see the question and think Read The Fucking Manual and downvote. Then you have zero karma and you can't do anything else.

The problem is that the Newb doesn't even know where to start in the manual.

mkoryak4y ago

If you want, I'll give you some points by making a bounty on some old question and giving it to you. You have to answer it though.

naragOP4y ago

Thank you, but this was never something that I wanted to do for my own interest.

I just saw someone with an unsolved problem and found out that I'd had to go through loops to help, so I gave up.

Actually it seems that owners became rich and it's now a popular site without my help, so I guess it can still survive without me :)

joe4633694y ago

As helpful as you no doubt would be, until you interact with SO in some way you're indistinguishable from a misleading moron.

naragOP4y ago

That wasn't a problem in any of the other forums I've contributed to. Go figure!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse